Most English adjectives can appear in two positions: directly before the noun (attributive position — a tired teacher) or after a linking verb (predicative position — the teacher is tired). For most adjectives these two positions are interchangeable. But a small and important set of adjectives can only appear in one position. Some are only attributive (the main problem — not: the problem is main). Some are only predicative (the teacher is asleep — not: the asleep teacher). Knowing these exceptions and being able to explain the distinction clearly is an important marker of grammatical precision.
Before you start — think honestly about your own teaching and experience.
Look at the examples. Answer each question before reading the explanation — this is how your students will learn too.
What is different about the adjectives in group C and D?
Most adjectives, like tired and happy, move freely between attributive (before the noun) and predicative (after a linking verb) positions without any change in meaning. But asleep and afraid resist the attributive position — an asleep student and an afraid child both sound wrong to native speakers. These adjectives are predicative-only: they can only appear after a linking verb (is, was, seems, feels, looks). They cannot directly precede a noun. Other predicative-only adjectives: awake, alive, alone, aware, ashamed, alike, adrift, ablaze. Notice that many of these begin with a- — this is a historical feature of Old English where the a- prefix marked a present participial or adjectival form that was used predicatively. Teaching the a- pattern as a group makes them easier to remember.
What do main, sheer, mere, and sole have in common? Why can they only appear before the noun?
Main, sheer, mere, sole, and utter are adjectives that only appear in attributive position — directly before the noun. They cannot be used predicatively after a linking verb. The problem is main is not standard English. These adjectives are called attributive-only adjectives. Interestingly, these adjectives often have an intensifying or limiting function — they emphasise or restrict the noun. Main (= most important), sheer (= nothing but/pure), mere (= only/nothing more than), sole (= only one), utter (= complete/total). Their meaning is so closely tied to modifying the noun that they do not work well when separated from it by a linking verb.
A: She was alone in the classroom. (predicative — correct)
B: The alone teacher marked books all evening. (attributive — wrong) → The teacher alone marked books. (different meaning) OR: The solitary teacher marked books all evening. (correct)
What is the pattern for correcting predicative-only adjectives when you need to use them attributively?
When a predicative-only adjective needs to be used to modify a noun attributively, there are two strategies: (1) use a different adjective that has the same meaning but works in attributive position: asleep → sleeping, afraid → frightened or scared, alone → solitary, awake → alert or wakeful; (2) use a relative clause: the student who was asleep, the child who was afraid, the teacher who was alone. Both strategies are natural and correct. Knowing these alternatives makes it easier to help learners who have produced errors with predicative-only adjectives in attributive position.'
| Tense / Form | Use / Meaning | Example | Key time words |
|---|---|---|---|
| Position | Description | Examples | |
| Attributive (before noun) | Adjective comes directly before the noun it modifies | a tired teacher / the main problem / an old building | |
| Predicative (after linking verb) | Adjective comes after be, seem, feel, look, become, appear | The teacher is tired. / The problem seems serious. / She looks nervous. | |
| Both positions (most adjectives) | Freely used in both positions | a tired teacher / the teacher is tired — both natural | |
| Predicative-only adjectives | ONLY after a linking verb — NOT before a noun | asleep, awake, alive, alone, afraid, aware, ashamed, alike, adrift, ablaze | |
| Attributive-only adjectives | ONLY before a noun — NOT after a linking verb | main, sole, utter, sheer, mere, former, latter, eventual, overall | |
| Alternatives for predicative-only adjectives | Use a synonym OR a relative clause | asleep → sleeping / the child who was asleep |
WHY SOME ADJECTIVES BEGIN WITH A-
Many predicative-only adjectives in English begin with a-: asleep, awake, alive, alone, afraid, aware, ashamed, alike, adrift, ablaze. This is not a coincidence — it is a historical feature. These a- forms developed from Old English and Middle English prepositional phrases (on sleep, on life, on fire) which gradually fused into single words. The a- prefix originally marked them as verbal or participial in nature, which is why they do not sit naturally in attributive position (before a noun) the way ordinary adjectives do. Knowing this history helps teachers understand the pattern and gives learners a useful memory aid: if an adjective begins with a- and describes a state, it is probably predicative-only.
CONTEXT-DEPENDENT ADJECTIVES
Some adjectives change meaning depending on their position. A certain teacher (attributive) means a specific unnamed teacher. The teacher is certain (predicative) means the teacher is sure about something. A responsible person (attributive) = someone who has responsibility or is dependable. The person is responsible (predicative) = the person caused something / is to blame. These position-sensitive meaning changes are worth knowing at an advanced level — they show that attributive and predicative positions are not always semantically interchangeable even for adjectives that appear in both.
FORMER AND LATTER
Former and latter are attributive-only adjectives that appear frequently in formal writing. Former refers to the first of two things just mentioned; latter refers to the second. Between the two options — morning and afternoon sessions — the former is already fully booked. The latter still has places. Former and latter are formal alternatives to the first one and the second one and signal a formal register in written prose.
ATTRIBUTIVE OR PREDICATIVE — AND IS IT RESTRICTED? - Is the adjective before the noun? → Attributive position. - Is the adjective after be, seem, feel, look, become, appear? → Predicative position. - Does the adjective begin with a- (asleep, awake, alive, alone, afraid, aware)? → Probably predicative-only — do not place before a noun. - Is the adjective one of main, sole, utter, sheer, mere, former, latter? → Attributive-only — do not place after a linking verb. - Trying to use a predicative-only adjective before a noun? → Use a synonym (sleeping, frightened, solitary) or a relative clause (who was asleep).
Decide whether the adjective in brackets can be used in the given position. If not, write the correct version.
Each sentence has an error involving an attributive-only or predicative-only adjective. Write the correct sentence and explain the mistake.
Use this sequence directly in class — guided discovery, no textbook needed. Tap each step to mark it done.
STEP 1 — TWO POSITIONS (5 minutes): Write on the board: a tired teacher (attributive) / The teacher is tired (predicative). Ask: what is the difference in position? Establish: attributive = before noun; predicative = after linking verb. Confirm that for most adjectives, both positions are natural and the meaning is the same.
STEP 2 — PREDICATIVE-ONLY: THE A- PATTERN (8 minutes): Write the a- adjectives on the board: asleep, awake, alive, alone, afraid, aware, ashamed, alike. Ask: can you say the asleep student? The alive fish? The afraid child? Confirm these all sound wrong — these adjectives only work after a linking verb. Introduce the a- historical pattern as a memory aid. Give the attributive synonyms for each: sleeping, alert, living, solitary, frightened, conscious, embarrassed, identical.
STEP 3 — ATTRIBUTIVE-ONLY: MAIN, SOLE, UTTER, SHEER (7 minutes): Write five sentences using main, sole, utter, sheer, mere after a linking verb (the problem is main, the luck was sheer). Ask: do these sound natural? Establish that these adjectives only work before the noun. Ask learners to produce correct versions (the main problem, sheer luck). Ask: why might these adjectives only work attributively? Draw out their intensifying/limiting function.
STEP 4 — CORRECTION STRATEGIES (5 minutes): Present three errors using predicative-only adjectives in attributive position. Ask learners to correct each using: (1) a synonym, and (2) a relative clause. Practise both strategies so learners have two reliable tools.
STEP 5 — PRODUCE AND TEST (5 minutes): Ask learners to write six sentences — three using predicative-only adjectives correctly (after a linking verb) and three using attributive-only adjectives correctly (before a noun). Share with a partner who checks the positions. Invite two or three learners to share their sentences.
Use directly in class — copy, adapt, or read aloud. No printing needed.
For each strategy, choose the option that best describes where you are now.
Your feedback helps other teachers and helps us improve TeachAnyClass.