On 11 September 2001, two planes were flown into the twin towers of the World Trade Center in New York City. Almost 3,000 people were killed. It was the deadliest attack on the United States in its history. Many people who were in the buildings that morning needed to find a way out. Some used internal fire stairs. Some were helped by firefighters and police officers, many of whom died in the buildings. Some found their way through smoke and rubble to the outside of the complex. At the northern edge of the World Trade Center plaza, there was an ordinary outdoor staircase connecting the elevated plaza to the pavement on Vesey Street below. The staircase had thirty-seven steps. On the morning of 11 September, hundreds of people used it to escape. They crossed the open plaza, with debris falling from the North Tower above, and reached these steps. For many of them, the stairs marked the moment they reached safety. The staircase survived the collapse of both towers. It was the last above-ground structure from the original World Trade Center still standing. For several years, it simply sat at the edge of the cleared site while people argued about what to do with it. Some wanted it preserved where it was. Others said it was in the way of rebuilding. In 2008, a crane lifted it off its foundations and moved it about 60 metres along Vesey Street. In 2010, it was lowered into what would become the basement of the new National September 11 Memorial and Museum. The museum was built above it. Today, visitors walk down past the staircase as they enter the main exhibition. An ordinary set of stairs became one of the most important objects in a country's memory of the worst day in its recent history. This lesson asks why — and what that teaches us about memory, loss, and the choices communities make about what to keep.
Because it is specific and it is real. Memorials for large events can become abstract. Numbers become too large to imagine. The staircase is thirty-seven specific steps that specific people walked down on a specific morning. It is a piece of the event that you can stand next to. You can touch it. Survivors remember it. Families of those who died passed it without knowing what was going to happen. It is also a piece of survival, which is a rarer kind of memorial focus than loss. Most memorials focus on the dead. The staircase stands for the people who got out. Students should think about why specific, physical objects often carry meaning that larger numbers or abstract descriptions cannot. The staircase is one concrete step at a time. That concreteness is part of why it matters.
These are genuinely hard questions. The site involved: the families of almost 3,000 dead people, hundreds of survivors, the city of New York, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the developers who owned parts of the site, the US federal government, preservation organisations, and the public. Everyone had a stake. Not everyone agreed. The process took years and involved public debate, legal negotiations, and political decisions. The staircase is one small example of a much larger series of decisions: what to rebuild, what to memorialize, what names to include, what story to tell, what to show in the museum. Every one of these decisions is contested. Strong answers will see that preservation is always a political act. It involves choosing whose memory matters, whose story gets told, and what future generations will see. The staircase is now a very powerful teaching object. But it nearly became rubble.
Architecture is communication. Every decision in memorial design carries meaning. Descending into the museum means going below street level, into the ground — like the underground space where so much of the horror of 11 September happened in the collapse. Passing the staircase means passing a real object from that morning, not a replica or a model. The names on the reflecting pools are read at the surface, in open air and daylight — the survivors' world. The memorial is serious and large-scale. The museum is specific and detailed. The combination asks visitors to hold both at once: the scale of the loss and the particularity of each life. Students should think about other examples of memorial design: the Vietnam Veterans Memorial wall in Washington (names engraved in black stone, visitors see their own reflections), the Holocaust Memorial in Berlin (a field of concrete blocks of different heights), the memorial at Srebrenica (white grave markers across a hillside). Each uses physical space and materials to communicate something about what happened. The Survivors' Staircase fits into this tradition.
This is an open question that should generate honest discussion. Possibilities include: Who died, and why does their death matter? What choices were made before, during, and after the event? Who was responsible? What happened next? What might have been done differently? Who benefited from the memorial and who did not? Whose voices are included and whose are missing? Strong answers will see that a good memorial does not simply make visitors feel sad or patriotic. A good memorial asks hard questions. It holds complexity. It does not erase difficult parts of the story. The September 11 museum has been praised for its honesty about the events of that day and criticised by some for presenting a particular political view of what followed. This is a real ongoing discussion. Students should see that memorials are not finished objects. They are part of continuing conversations about what happened and what it means.
The Survivors' Staircase is a concrete and granite outdoor staircase, with thirty-seven steps, that was part of the original World Trade Center complex in New York City. On 11 September 2001, hundreds of people used it to escape after two planes were flown into the twin towers. It was the last above-ground surviving structure of the original complex. After years of debate about whether to demolish or preserve it, it was moved by crane in 2008 and lowered into the space that became the National September 11 Memorial and Museum. The museum opened in 2014. Visitors pass the staircase as they descend into the museum. The staircase is both a physical object from 11 September 2001 and a lesson in how communities make decisions about memory, preservation, and the stories they want to tell future generations.
| Question | What many people assume | What is actually true |
|---|---|---|
| Was the staircase damaged by the attacks? | Yes | The damage visible today was caused by demolition work after 2001, not by the attacks themselves |
| Was the staircase always going to be preserved? | Yes | It was nearly demolished in 2006. Survivors and preservation groups campaigned for years to save it |
| Is the staircase a replica? | Many think it might be | It is the real staircase, in its actual damaged state, moved from its original location by crane |
| How many steps does it have? | Unclear | Thirty-seven steps. It originally weighed 175 tons |
| Who owns and manages it? | The US government | The National September 11 Memorial and Museum is a non-profit organisation, though it receives public funding |
| When did the museum open? | Soon after the attacks | The museum opened in 2014, thirteen years after the attacks. Decisions about the site took many years of negotiation |
The September 11 attacks were the first major terrorist attack on the United States.
There had been earlier attacks, including a bomb at the World Trade Center in 1993 that killed six people and injured over a thousand. The 11 September attacks were far larger in scale but not the beginning of terrorism in the US.
Presenting 11 September as entirely unprecedented can erase earlier history and make it harder to understand the full context.
The Survivors' Staircase is a replica built for the museum.
It is the real staircase, in its actual damaged state, moved from its original location at the World Trade Center site by crane in 2008. The damage visible is from demolition work after 2001, not from the attacks.
Students often assume museum objects of this kind are copies. The physical reality of the original object is a large part of its power.
There was no debate about what to do with the September 11 site — it was always going to be a memorial.
The decisions about what to rebuild, what to memorialize, and what to preserve involved years of negotiation between many groups with different interests. The staircase itself was nearly demolished. Nothing about the site was automatic.
Presenting the memorial as an inevitable, uncontested choice hides the real difficulty of how communities make decisions about loss.
All Muslims or all Arabs were responsible for the attacks, or were suspected of involvement.
The attacks were carried out by a specific group, al-Qaeda. The vast majority of Muslims and Arabs around the world condemned them. After the attacks, many Muslim and Arab communities in the United States and elsewhere faced discrimination and violence that was wrong and unjust.
This misconception has caused real harm to real communities and must be corrected clearly and without ambiguity.
Treat this lesson with the same care you would use for any recent tragedy involving living survivors and grieving families. Many people alive today lost family members on 11 September 2001. Some of your students may have family connections to the events. Be attentive to this without putting students on the spot. Do not ask students to share personal connections unless they volunteer. The attacks were carried out by members of al-Qaeda. Be clear about this and equally clear that they do not represent Islam, Arabs, or any other group. Islamophobia and anti-Arab racism that followed the attacks caused real harm to real communities. Include this in the lesson. Do not present the United States as simply a victim without also noting the wars that followed and their consequences. The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq killed many civilians. These are part of the history of 11 September. The lesson focuses on the staircase and the questions of memory and memorialisation, not on the political and military response, but you should be honest if students ask. The museum has been praised for the quality of its exhibits and criticised by some for its presentation. Some families of victims have raised concerns about various aspects of the museum. Treat this as a real ongoing conversation, not a settled matter. Be careful with images. Do not show graphic images of the attacks, the falling towers, or the dead. The staircase itself is a dignified and appropriate image. If using other images, select them carefully. Use the official name: the National September 11 Memorial and Museum. The attacks are referred to as the September 11 attacks, 11 September 2001, or 9/11. All three are in common use. Avoid graphic descriptions of how people died. The lesson is about survival and memory, not about the details of the violence. End the lesson on the present: the staircase is still there, the memorial is still visited, the questions it raises are still being asked.
Answer each question in one or two sentences. Use what you have learned about the Survivors' Staircase.
What is the Survivors' Staircase and where is it now?
Why was there a debate about whether to keep the staircase?
How is the staircase displayed in the museum, and why does the display design matter?
What does the term 'contested memory' mean? Give one example from the lesson.
Why is it important to be clear that the September 11 attacks do not represent all Muslims or Arabs?
These questions have no single right answer. Talk in pairs or small groups, then share your ideas with the class.
The Survivors' Staircase was nearly demolished. What other objects from major historical events might have been lost and were not? What does this tell us about how preservation decisions get made?
The museum charges an entrance fee. Some families of victims say it should be free. Others say the fee is necessary to keep the museum running. What do you think?
If your community experienced a major disaster or tragic event, what object from that event do you think should be preserved? What would you do with it?
Your feedback helps other teachers and helps us improve TeachAnyClass.
