All Texts
Report
Obituary

Dr Awa Diallo: An Obituary

📂 Lives, Medicine, And Public Service 🎭 The Obituary Of A Pioneering Doctor Who Worked In Rural Medicine And Public Health For Over Fifty Years ⏱ 20–55 min
About this text
🎯 Learning objectives
  • Follow the life of one person across eight decades and six levels of complexity
  • Use vocabulary for medicine, public health, biography, and obituary writing accurately
  • Identify direct quotations from family, colleagues, patients, and officials and explain what each adds
  • Discuss what an obituary is for, and what it can and cannot do
  • Compare a respectful obituary with a more analytical biographical essay
  • Write a short obituary using a clear opening, balanced supporting voices, and a sense of the life as a whole
  • Talk about service, vocation, and the relationship between individual lives and wider history
💡 Ideas for using this in a lesson
  • Read only the headline and the opening paragraph. In pairs, predict what kind of life will follow. Read on and check.
  • Underline every fact in the opening (when she was born, where, what she did, when she died). Discuss what each adds.
  • Role-play in pairs: one student is a journalist, one is a colleague of Dr Diallo. The journalist asks: 'What was she like to work with? What was she most proud of?'
  • Find every direct quotation. In pairs, discuss what each adds. Why does the obituary need each one?
  • Cultural sharing: in groups, students describe a person from their region whose life is remembered locally. What did the person do? Who tells the story?
  • In groups, students rewrite the opening paragraph in three voices: a national newspaper, a small medical journal, and a village radio bulletin.
  • Vocabulary mapping: in pairs, sort vocabulary into 'medicine and health', 'biography and life-stages', 'people and places', 'civic and administrative language'.
  • Writing task at level: students write a short obituary for a fictional person whose life they have invented — a teacher, a farmer, a mechanic, an organiser. They must include numbers, places, and at least one quotation.
  • Discussion in groups: what does an obituary do that other kinds of writing about a life cannot do? Different angles for different cultural traditions.
  • Compare two levels: in pairs, students read the same paragraph at A2 and B2 and identify three things the higher level adds.
🏷️ Context
Low ResourcePairworkDiscussion RichBiographicalIntercultural
📦 Materials needed
Paper And Pen
⚠️ The text is an obituary — a piece of writing about a person who has just died. The doctor and her country are fictional, but the kind of life described will be familiar in many regions of the global south, where individual women working against considerable obstacles have shaped public health over the second half of the twentieth century and the early twenty-first. The piece is gentle and not melodramatic. There is no graphic medical detail. Death itself is treated with the calm care that is the obituary's traditional register. Some students may have lost relatives recently, or may come from cultures where talking about the dead in particular ways is sensitive. Teachers should let conversation stay at a level the class is comfortable with, and not press for personal stories of loss. The higher levels reflect on the form of the obituary itself, on questions of representation, and on the relationship between individual life and structural history; these are intellectually interesting rather than emotionally heavy.
⏱ Duration by level
A1
20 min
A2
25 min
B1
35 min
B2
45 min
C1
50 min
C2
55 min
🎚️ Differentiation tip
If you have a mixed-level class, give the lower-level students the A1 or A2 version and the higher-level students the B2 or C1 version, then bring them together for the discussion. The lower-level students can describe what Dr Diallo did — when she was born, where she worked, what she was known for — and the higher-level students can discuss what the obituary form does and what it leaves out. Both groups gain. The lower level hears the wider conversation; the higher level has to express it accessibly. For weaker readers at any level, pre-teach four or five key words (doctor, clinic, hospital, train, born, died) before reading. For stronger readers, you can skip the vocabulary section and go straight to discussion, which is where the level really earns its difficulty.
🌍 Cultural note
The obituary as a written form has different shapes in different cultures. In some traditions, public writing about a person who has just died is direct, factual, and quickly published; in others, it is much more restrained, ceremonial, or reserved for community speech rather than print. In many parts of the global south, the obituary as a published genre coexists with older oral traditions of remembering — songs, eulogies, village gatherings — that may carry more weight than the written version. Students will come from across this range, and discussion should make space for that variety. The text describes a particular kind of obituary in a particular kind of newspaper; it does not claim this is what writing about the dead looks like everywhere, or that the published form is the most important way of remembering. Some students may also have specific religious or cultural practices around naming the dead, speaking of them, or reading about them; teachers should be sensitive to these without making them the subject of the lesson.
Beginner
Intermediate
Advanced
Duration: 20 min 🎯 Focus: Past simple. Was/were. Years and ages. Words for family, work, and places. Words for medicine.
Before You Read / Listen
  • Q1What is a 'doctor'? What does a doctor do?
  • Q2What is a 'clinic'? Is it bigger or smaller than a hospital?
  • Q3Where is your doctor? In a city or in a village?
  • Q4If a person is the first one to do something, we say they are a 'first'. Can you think of a 'first' in your country?
  • Q5When a person who did good work dies, who remembers them?
The Text
Dr Awa Diallo died last Sunday. She was eighty-four years old. She was a doctor in our country for more than fifty years.
Awa Diallo was born in 1941, in a small town called Mansa. Her father was a teacher. Her mother sold cloth in the market.
Awa was the third of seven children. She was clever. She liked school. Her father said: "This girl will study." Many people in the town said girls did not need school. Her father did not listen to them.
Awa went to the secondary school in the city. Then she went to medical school. She was the first girl from Mansa to be a doctor. She was one of the first ten women in our country to be a doctor.
She finished her training in 1968. She did not stay in the city. She went back to her town. She opened a small clinic next to the market. The clinic had three rooms.
For fifty years, Awa worked at this clinic. She helped mothers when babies were born. She gave the children injections. She taught families how to clean water. She walked to villages with no roads.
In the 1980s, Awa worked with the government. She helped to make a plan for the health of children in the country. She still kept her clinic in Mansa. She drove to the city in the week. She drove home for the weekend.
Awa got married in 1972. Her husband, Mr Bah, was an engineer. They had four children. Three of her children are now doctors too. One is a teacher.
She had many students. Many of the doctors in our country knew her. Some of them lived in her house when they were students. They called her "Mama Awa."
Mr Sory Camara, a doctor in Mansa now, was one of her students. He said: "She taught me how to listen to a patient. She told me: do not be in a hurry. Sit. Listen. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing."
Dr Diallo died at her home in Mansa, on Sunday morning. Her family was with her. The clinic was closed for one day. It will open again on Wednesday. Her son, Dr Ibrahim Bah, will work there now.
Many people will remember her. The doctors. The mothers. The children, who are now adults. Mansa is a small town. Almost every family knew her. Almost every family will remember her name.
Key Vocabulary
doctor noun
a person who is trained to help sick people
"Dr Awa Diallo was a doctor for more than fifty years."
clinic noun
a small place where a doctor sees patients
"She opened a small clinic next to the market."
to die / death verb / noun
(verb) to stop living / (noun) the end of a person's life
"Dr Awa Diallo died last Sunday."
born / to be born verb
to come into life
"She was born in 1941."
town noun
a place where people live, smaller than a city, bigger than a village
"A small town called Mansa."
to study / studies verb
to learn at a school or university
"This girl will study."
to train / training verb / noun
to learn the skills for a job
"She finished her training in 1968."
patient noun
a person who is being helped by a doctor
"She taught me how to listen to a patient."
to remember verb
to keep someone or something in your mind
"Many people will remember her."
family noun
the people you are related to — parents, brothers, sisters, children
"Her family was with her."
Questions
Comprehension
  • When did Dr Awa Diallo die, and how old was she?
    Answer
    She died last Sunday. She was eighty-four years old.
  • Where and when was she born? What did her parents do?
    Answer
    She was born in 1941, in a small town called Mansa. Her father was a teacher. Her mother sold cloth in the market.
  • Why was Awa special when she was young?
    Answer
    She was the third of seven children. She was clever. She liked school. Her father said she would study. Many people said girls did not need school, but her father did not listen to them.
  • Where did she go to study, and what kind of doctor was she?
    Answer
    She went to secondary school in the city, then to medical school. She was the first girl from Mansa to be a doctor. She was one of the first ten women in the country to be a doctor.
  • What did she do after she finished her training?
    Answer
    She did not stay in the city. She went back to her town. She opened a small clinic next to the market. The clinic had three rooms.
  • Name three things she did at the clinic.
    Answer
    She helped mothers when babies were born. She gave the children injections. She taught families how to clean water. She walked to villages with no roads.
  • What did she do in the 1980s?
    Answer
    She worked with the government. She helped to make a plan for the health of children in the country. She still kept her clinic in Mansa. She drove to the city in the week and home for the weekend.
  • What did Dr Sory Camara say about her?
    Answer
    He said: 'She taught me how to listen to a patient. She told me: do not be in a hurry. Sit. Listen. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing.'
Vocabulary
  • What is a 'clinic'?
    Answer
    A small place where a doctor sees patients. It is smaller than a hospital.
  • What does 'to be born' mean?
    Answer
    To come into life. The article says: 'She was born in 1941.'
Discussion
  • Many doctors called Dr Diallo 'Mama Awa'. Why?
    Discussion prompts
    Prompts for discussion: KIND — she was kind to her students. RESPECT — 'Mama' shows respect for an older woman. HOME — some students lived in her house; she was like a mother. WARM — calling her 'Mama' is warmer than 'Doctor'. Useful for talking about names and respect.
Personal
  • Is there a doctor, nurse, or teacher in your community who is loved by many people? What do they do?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'A doctor in my village; everyone knows him'; 'A teacher who taught my mother'; 'A midwife in our town'; 'No, our doctor is new'. Be warm. The question is good for vocabulary about people and roles.
  • What is one thing you would like people to remember about you? It can be small.
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'That I was a good friend'; 'That I helped my family'; 'That I worked hard at school'; 'That I cooked well'; 'I do not know yet'. Be warm. The question is reflective and gentle. Welcome quiet answers.
Writing Task
Prompt
Write a short story (60–80 words) about a person you know or have heard about. Tell us: who they are, where they live, what they do, and one good thing about them. Use past simple and present simple.
Model Answer

My grandmother is eighty years old. She lives in a small village. She has a small farm with chickens and goats. She has eight grandchildren. She cooks for many people every Sunday. When I was a small child, she taught me how to tie my shoes. She is patient. She does not get angry. She listens. Many people in our village come to her with problems. She does not always have answers, but she always listens.

Activities
  • Read the obituary out loud in pairs. One student reads, the other listens. Then change.
  • Find all the numbers in the story (eighty-four, 1941, three of seven, first ten, three rooms, fifty years, 1968, 1972, four children). Discuss what each tells us.
  • In pairs, draw a simple timeline of Awa's life. Mark: born, school, medical school, clinic, marriage, government work, death.
  • Match game: write the words on small papers. In pairs, mix them and match each word with its meaning.
  • Role-play: student A is Dr Sory Camara, student B is a journalist. The journalist asks: 'How long did you know her? What did she teach you? What will you remember?'
  • Sentence building: complete the sentences. 'She was born in ___.' 'She went to ___ in the city.' 'She had ___ children.' 'She worked at the clinic for ___ years.'
  • Cultural sharing: in pairs, students describe a doctor or teacher they know. Where do they work? Who do they help?
Duration: 25 min 🎯 Focus: Past simple. Past continuous. Reported speech. Time markers (in those days, by the time, after that, throughout her life).
Before You Read / Listen
  • Q1When you read about a person's life in a newspaper, what do you usually want to know?
  • Q2Why do some people stay in their home town after they study, instead of going to a big city?
  • Q3What kinds of work change a community for a long time? Why?
  • Q4Have you read or heard a story about a person who was the first to do something difficult? What did the person do?
  • Q5When a respected person dies, what do communities do to remember them?
The Text
Dr Awa Diallo, who was one of the first ten women in our country to qualify as a doctor and who ran a small clinic in her home town of Mansa for more than fifty years, died at her home on Sunday morning. She was eighty-four. Her family was with her.
Awa Diallo was born in Mansa in 1941. Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher; her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader in the market. Awa was the third of seven children. "She was the one who asked questions," her younger brother, Mr Boubacar Diallo, said this week. "She asked them at home. She asked them at school. Our father was very pleased. Our mother said the questions tired her, but she was proud."
In those days, very few girls in our country went to secondary school. Awa was the first girl from Mansa to do so. After secondary school, she went to medical school in the capital. She qualified in 1968, at the age of twenty-six. She was, by any measure, an exception.
When she finished her training, she could have stayed in the city, where the work was easier and the salary was higher. She did not. She went back to Mansa, where there had been no doctor for the previous twelve years. She opened a small clinic next to the market, in a building her father helped her rent. The clinic had three rooms and a small garden where she grew herbs.
For the next half-century, Awa Diallo worked at the clinic. She delivered babies, treated children's fevers, taught families how to make water safe to drink, and walked, when there were no roads, to villages on the edge of the town. "She was tired every day," her daughter, Dr Aissatou Bah, said. "But she did not stop. She used to say: 'When I stop, who comes next?'"
In the 1980s, the government asked Awa Diallo to help write the country's first national plan for child health. She agreed, on the condition that she could keep her clinic. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings, for nine years. The plan she helped to write was used until the early 2000s, and is widely thought to have saved many thousands of children's lives.
She married Mr Ibrahima Bah, an engineer, in 1972. They had four children. Three of them — Aissatou, Ibrahim, and Salimatou — are now doctors. The fourth, Mariama, is a primary school teacher. "My mother did not push us into medicine," Dr Aissatou Bah said. "She did not push us into anything. She let us see what she did. Three of us chose it. One did not. She was equally proud of all of us."
Many of the doctors in our country today were Awa Diallo's students. She trained them at the clinic during their final year of medical school, when each was sent to a rural posting. Several lived in her house. They called her "Mama Awa."
Dr Sory Camara, who is now in charge of the clinic in Mansa with Dr Ibrahim Bah, was one of those students. "She taught me how to listen," he said. "She would say: 'Do not be in a hurry. Sit down. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing.' She was right. I have been a doctor for nineteen years. She was always right."
Dr Awa Diallo received several honours late in her life — including the national medal for service in 2009 — but the photographs from her clinic show her in the same simple cotton dress and white coat she had worn since the 1970s. She did not, by all accounts, change much. "She did not need to," her son Dr Ibrahim Bah said. "She had decided who she was going to be when she was twenty. She was that person until the day she died."
Dr Diallo is survived by her husband, her four children, and twelve grandchildren. The funeral will be held in Mansa on Friday morning. The clinic has been closed since Sunday and will reopen on Wednesday. Dr Ibrahim Bah and Dr Sory Camara will continue the work. "There will be no doctor like her," Dr Camara said. "That is the truth. But there will be the clinic. That is what she would have wanted."
Key Vocabulary
to qualify (as a doctor) verb
to finish the training that allows you to do a particular job
"She qualified in 1968."
exception noun
a person or thing that is not part of a common pattern
"She was, by any measure, an exception."
to deliver (a baby) verb
to help a baby be born
"She delivered babies, treated children's fevers..."
to treat (a patient) verb
to give medical care to a person who is ill
"Treated children's fevers."
national plan noun phrase
a plan made by the government for the whole country
"The country's first national plan for child health."
rural adjective
of the countryside, away from big cities
"Each was sent to a rural posting."
honour (an honour) noun
a public sign of respect, often a medal or a title
"She received several honours late in her life."
by all accounts phrase
according to what everyone says
"She did not, by all accounts, change much."
to be survived by (someone) phrase
(in obituaries) the family members who are still alive after a person dies
"Dr Diallo is survived by her husband, her four children, and twelve grandchildren."
funeral noun
the ceremony for a person who has died
"The funeral will be held in Mansa on Friday morning."
in those days phrase
at that time in the past
"In those days, very few girls in our country went to secondary school."
Questions
Comprehension
  • When and where did Dr Diallo die, and how old was she?
    Answer
    She died at her home in Mansa on Sunday morning, with her family. She was eighty-four.
  • Who were her parents, and what did they do?
    Answer
    Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher. Her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader in the market. Awa was the third of seven children.
  • What did her brother say about her as a child?
    Answer
    Mr Boubacar Diallo said: 'She was the one who asked questions. She asked them at home. She asked them at school. Our father was very pleased. Our mother said the questions tired her, but she was proud.'
  • When did she qualify as a doctor, and what was unusual about it?
    Answer
    She qualified in 1968 at the age of twenty-six. Very few girls in the country went to secondary school in those days; she was the first girl from Mansa to do so. She was one of the first ten women in the country to qualify as a doctor.
  • Why was it unusual that she went back to Mansa instead of staying in the city?
    Answer
    She could have stayed in the city, where the work was easier and the salary was higher. She did not. She went back to Mansa, where there had been no doctor for the previous twelve years.
  • What did Awa do at the clinic for fifty years?
    Answer
    She delivered babies, treated children's fevers, taught families how to make water safe to drink, and walked, when there were no roads, to villages on the edge of the town.
  • What did she do for the government in the 1980s?
    Answer
    The government asked her to help write the country's first national plan for child health. She agreed, on the condition that she could keep her clinic. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings for nine years. The plan was used until the early 2000s and is widely thought to have saved many thousands of children's lives.
  • Who was she married to, and what about her children?
    Answer
    She married Mr Ibrahima Bah, an engineer, in 1972. They had four children. Three of them are now doctors. The fourth is a primary school teacher. Her daughter says she did not push them into medicine, and was equally proud of all of them.
  • What did Dr Sory Camara say she taught him?
    Answer
    She taught him how to listen. She would say: 'Do not be in a hurry. Sit down. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing.' He has been a doctor for nineteen years and says she was always right.
Vocabulary
  • What does 'to be survived by' mean in this article?
    Answer
    In the language of obituaries, it lists the family members who are still alive after the person has died. The article says: 'Dr Diallo is survived by her husband, her four children, and twelve grandchildren.'
  • What does 'by all accounts' mean?
    Answer
    According to what everyone says. When the article says 'she did not, by all accounts, change much,' it means that this is what everyone who knew her reports — not just one person.
Inference
  • Why did Awa say 'when I stop, who comes next?'
    Suggested interpretation
    Because there was no other doctor in Mansa. If she stopped, the patients would have nowhere to go. The question is gentle but practical. It tells us how she thought about her tiredness — not as something to complain about, but as something the situation required of her.
  • Why does Dr Camara say 'There will be no doctor like her. That is the truth. But there will be the clinic. That is what she would have wanted'?
    Suggested interpretation
    He is being honest about two things at once: that she cannot be replaced, and that the work she built can continue without her. He is not pretending the loss is small. He is also saying that her aim was the clinic, not her own importance, and that continuing the clinic is the proper way of honouring her.
Discussion
  • Awa Diallo could have stayed in the capital, where the work was easier. Was she right to go back to Mansa? Was the choice a sacrifice or what she really wanted?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — Mansa needed a doctor; staying in the city would have multiplied her own salary but not the country's health. SACRIFICE — she gave up money, ease, and city opportunities. WHAT SHE WANTED — the article suggests she did not feel she was giving anything up; she wanted to be the doctor of her town. PROBABLY ALL THREE — sacrifice is real even when it is what one wants. A useful question.
Personal
  • Is there a person you know — or have heard about — whose work helped many people quietly, without much attention? Tell us about them.
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My grandmother who delivered many babies in our village'; 'A teacher in my school'; 'A man who fixed bicycles for free for the children'; 'A neighbour who looked after the old people on our street'; 'I have not yet thought about this'. Be warm.
Writing Task
Prompt
Write a short obituary (130–160 words) for a person you have invented — a teacher, a farmer, a nurse, a shopkeeper. Include: when they were born and died, where they lived, what they were known for, and at least one quotation from a family member or colleague. Use past simple and reported speech.
Model Answer

Mrs Hadiya Khan, who taught primary school in the village of Bardiya for forty-two years and was loved by three generations of children, died at her home on Tuesday. She was eighty-six.

Mrs Khan was born in the village in 1939, in a small house near the school where she would later teach. She trained as a teacher in the regional capital and returned to Bardiya in 1958, when the school had only one classroom. By the time she retired in 2000, the school had six classrooms and over two hundred pupils.

Mr Salim Park, a farmer and former pupil, said: "She taught my mother. She taught me. She taught my children. We did not always like her — she was strict — but we always trusted her."

Mrs Khan is survived by her husband, three children, and seven grandchildren. The funeral will be held at the village mosque on Friday morning.

Activities
  • Find every direct quotation. In pairs, discuss what each adds. Why does the obituary need each one?
  • Time order: in groups, students draw a timeline from 1941 (born) to last Sunday (died). Mark each event from the article.
  • Vocabulary sort: in pairs, divide vocabulary into 'medicine and health', 'biography', 'civic and administrative language'.
  • Role-play: in groups of three, one student is Dr Camara, one is Awa's daughter, one is a journalist. The journalist asks each what they would like people to remember.
  • Tone comparison: in pairs, students rewrite one paragraph in the style of (a) a national newspaper, (b) a small village newsletter, (c) a medical journal. Discuss what each gains and loses.
  • Reading aloud in pairs: practise reading the quotations from Awa's brother, daughter, son, and student with the right feeling.
  • Sentence frames: 'She was the first ___ from ___ to ___.' 'She did not, by all accounts, ___.' 'She is survived by ___.' Each student writes three sentences using these frames.
  • Cultural sharing: in groups, students describe how their communities remember someone who has died. Public ceremonies? Quiet family gatherings? Songs?
  • Compare with A1: students read the same paragraph at A1 and A2 and find three things A2 adds (more characters, more careful framing, hedged claims like 'by all accounts').
Duration: 35 min 🎯 Focus: Past simple, past perfect for ordering events. Reported speech with a range of verbs (recall, insist, joke, observe). Cohesion devices: by then, however, although, in time. Hedged claims.
Before You Read / Listen
  • Q1There is a kind of life that, although remarkable in retrospect, was lived day by day in ordinary places. What does an obituary have to do to register both the daily ordinariness and the larger significance?
  • Q2Some 'firsts' — the first woman to do something, the first person from a particular town — are written into history; others are quietly forgotten. What makes the difference?
  • Q3When a doctor in a small place is loved across generations, the community's memory of her may include details (sayings, gestures, small kindnesses) that a national newspaper cannot easily fit. What is the difficulty for the obituary writer here?
  • Q4Many distinguished doctors of the second half of the twentieth century in the global south combined private practice with national policy work. What does this combination tell us about the period?
  • Q5What is the difference between an obituary that praises a person and one that lets the person be seen?
The Text
Dr Awa Diallo, who was one of the first ten women in our country to qualify as a doctor and who ran a small clinic in her home town of Mansa for more than fifty years, died at her home on Sunday morning, surrounded by her family. She was eighty-four. She had been ill for several months but had continued to see patients, in a reduced way, until February of this year.
Awa Diallo was born on 14 March 1941, in a small house on the edge of the market in Mansa, a town in the south of the country. Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher; her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader. Awa was the third of seven children, and the only daughter for the first nine years of her life. "She used to say that being the only girl was the best preparation for everything that came afterwards," her younger brother, Mr Boubacar Diallo, recalled this week. "She did not mean it was lonely. She meant that she had had to argue early."
In 1941, in Mansa, very few girls went past primary school. Awa was the first girl from the town to be sent to secondary school in the regional capital. Her father had to ask three different uncles to contribute to the cost. He told them, repeatedly, that the cost would be repaid in time. By all accounts, he was unusual in his certainty about this. By all accounts, he was right.
She qualified in medicine in 1968, at the age of twenty-six, from the country's then-only medical school. Of the forty-three students in her year, four were women. Two of those four left medicine within ten years; one became a hospital director in another country; only Awa Diallo went to a small place and stayed. "She used to say that staying was harder than the leaving," Dr Aissatou Bah, her eldest daughter and herself a doctor, said. "She did not mean it as a complaint. She meant that the work of building something is harder than people think, and the work of staying with what you have built is harder still."
She returned to Mansa in November 1968. There had been no doctor in the town for the previous twelve years. The nearest hospital was eighty kilometres away; the road, in the rains, was sometimes impassable for three or four days at a stretch. With a small loan from a community fund, and a building that her father helped her rent next to the market, she opened a clinic with three rooms — one for consultations, one for examinations, and one in which a single bed allowed her, in emergencies, to keep a patient overnight. She kept herbs in a small garden behind the building, and a list, in a hardcover notebook, of the families of every patient she saw. She kept the same kind of notebook, with the same kind of list, until 2019.
For fifty-one years, Dr Diallo worked at this clinic. The work changed in many ways. The list of medicines available to her grew. Vaccination programmes arrived; her clinic was, in the late 1970s, one of the first in the region to offer the new childhood vaccination schedule. The roads to the surrounding villages were, in the 1990s, finally paved; the journey to Tola, which had taken her two and a half hours on foot in 1971, took thirty-five minutes by car in 2001. Some things did not change. The hardcover notebooks remained. The white coat, which she had been given as a graduation present by her uncle, was repaired three times by a tailor in the market and was still in use in 2018.
In 1972, she married Mr Ibrahima Bah, an engineer who worked for the regional water authority and whom she had met at the wedding of a mutual cousin. They had four children, three of whom — Aissatou, Ibrahim, and Salimatou — are now doctors, and one of whom, Mariama, is a primary school teacher. Friends close to the family say that Dr Diallo was particularly clear, throughout her children's adolescence, that she did not want any of them to be doctors out of a sense of duty to her. "She told us we should choose what we wanted," Dr Aissatou Bah said. "She told us that being a doctor was hard, that it was sometimes lonely, that it should not be entered without thought. Three of us chose it anyway. Mariama did not. My mother used to say that of the four of us, Mariama was the one who had listened most carefully."
From 1981 to 1990, she served as a senior adviser on child health to the Ministry of Health. She had agreed to accept the post on one condition: that she could continue to run her clinic in Mansa. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings, for nine years. The plan she helped to draft — a primary care framework that emphasised vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, and the training of village health workers — became the basis of the national strategy until the early 2000s, and is widely thought, by those who study these things, to have saved a substantial number of children's lives.
She was, throughout her life, less interested in the formal recognition of her work than in the work itself. She received the national medal for service in 2009; she did not, by all accounts, attend the ceremony, sending her daughter Mariama in her place because the date conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa. She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014; the certificate hung, framed, on the wall of the clinic, but in the room used for storing files, where most patients did not see it. She gave one extended interview to a documentary team, in 2018, on the condition that the team also spoke at length with three of the village health workers she had trained, and that the resulting film be shown first in Mansa and only then sent to film festivals.
Dozens of doctors in our country today were trained, in the final year of their medical education, at her clinic. Some of them lived in her house during their rural posting. They called her "Mama Awa", a name she neither encouraged nor discouraged. Dr Sory Camara, who is now in charge of the clinic together with her son Dr Ibrahim Bah, was one of those students. "She taught me how to listen to a patient," he said. "She would say: 'Sit down. Do not be in a hurry. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing. The first thing they say is the easiest thing. Wait for the second thing.' I have been a doctor for nineteen years. She was always right."
Dr Diallo's husband, Mr Bah, died in 2018. She continued to work at the clinic, with reduced hours, until February of this year, when her own illness made consultation difficult. She is survived by her four children and twelve grandchildren. The funeral will be held in Mansa on Friday morning. The clinic, which has been closed since Sunday, will reopen on Wednesday. Dr Ibrahim Bah and Dr Sory Camara will continue the work. "There will be no doctor like her," Dr Camara said. "That is the truth. But there will be the clinic, and there will be the village health workers, and there will be the doctors she trained. That is the form her continuing will take, and it is, I think, the form she would have chosen."
Key Vocabulary
in retrospect phrase
looking back at something that has already happened, and seeing it more clearly than at the time
"A life that, in retrospect, was remarkable."
consultation (a medical consultation) noun
a meeting between a doctor and a patient to discuss a health problem
"One room for consultations."
vaccination programme noun phrase
an organised effort to give protective medicines to many people, especially children
"Vaccination programmes arrived."
framework (a primary care framework) noun
a basic structure of ideas and rules around which something is built
"A primary care framework that emphasised vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition."
village health worker noun phrase
a person trained to provide basic medical care in a rural community, often working under the supervision of doctors
"The training of village health workers."
antenatal clinic noun phrase
a medical service for women during pregnancy
"The date conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa."
to draft (a plan) verb
to write the first version of a plan or document
"The plan she helped to draft."
rural posting noun phrase
a temporary placement in the countryside, especially during medical training
"Some of them lived in her house during their rural posting."
to encourage / to discourage verbs
(verb) to give support that makes something more likely / (verb) to give discouragement that makes something less likely
"A name she neither encouraged nor discouraged."
by all accounts phrase
according to what everyone says
"She did not, by all accounts, attend the ceremony."
honorary fellow noun phrase
a person given the title 'fellow' of an organisation as an honour, without having to do the usual qualifying work
"She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014."
to be survived by phrase
(in obituaries) the family members who are still alive after a person dies
"She is survived by her four children and twelve grandchildren."
Questions
Comprehension
  • When and where was Awa Diallo born, and what did her parents do?
    Answer
    She was born on 14 March 1941, in a small house on the edge of the market in Mansa, a town in the south of the country. Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher. Her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader. Awa was the third of seven children and the only daughter for the first nine years of her life.
  • What did her father have to do to send her to secondary school, and what does the article say about him?
    Answer
    Her father had to ask three different uncles to contribute to the cost. He told them, repeatedly, that the cost would be repaid in time. By all accounts, he was unusual in his certainty about this. By all accounts, he was right.
  • What is significant about her cohort of medical students?
    Answer
    Of the forty-three students in her year at the country's then-only medical school, four were women. Two of those four left medicine within ten years; one became a hospital director in another country. Only Awa Diallo went to a small place and stayed.
  • What did the clinic look like when she opened it, and what does the article say did not change?
    Answer
    Three rooms — one for consultations, one for examinations, and one with a single bed for emergency overnight stays. She kept herbs in a small garden behind the building, and a hardcover notebook list of the families of every patient she saw. She kept the same kind of notebook, with the same kind of list, until 2019. The white coat she had been given as a graduation present was repaired three times and was still in use in 2018.
  • What did Awa say about being a doctor to her own children?
    Answer
    She told them they should choose what they wanted. She told them being a doctor was hard, that it was sometimes lonely, and that it should not be entered without thought. Three chose it anyway. Mariama did not. Awa used to say that of the four, Mariama was the one who had listened most carefully.
  • What did she do for the Ministry of Health from 1981 to 1990?
    Answer
    She served as a senior adviser on child health, on the condition that she could continue to run her clinic in Mansa. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings for nine years. The plan she helped to draft — a primary care framework emphasising vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, and the training of village health workers — became the basis of the national strategy until the early 2000s and is widely thought to have saved a substantial number of children's lives.
  • What does the article say about her response to formal recognition?
    Answer
    She was less interested in formal recognition than in the work itself. She received the national medal for service in 2009 but did not attend the ceremony, sending her daughter Mariama in her place because the date conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa. She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014; the certificate hung in the room used for storing files, where most patients did not see it. She gave one documentary interview in 2018, on the condition that three of the village health workers she had trained were also interviewed at length and that the film be shown first in Mansa.
Vocabulary
  • What is a 'village health worker', and why is this role central to the article?
    Answer
    A village health worker is a person trained to provide basic medical care in a rural community, often under the supervision of doctors. The role is central because Dr Diallo's national plan emphasised the training of village health workers as a way to make primary care available in places where doctors could not reach. Recognising her contribution at the national level depends on understanding this role.
  • What is the rhetorical work of 'by all accounts' in this article?
    Answer
    It is doing two things. First, it is a hedge — the writer is sourcing the claim, in effect, to general report rather than to personal observation. Second, it is gentle rather than dramatic; it allows the writer to make significant claims (her father was unusual; she did not change much) without sounding like a hagiography. The phrase appears several times in the article and forms part of its restrained register.
  • What does the writer mean by 'a name she neither encouraged nor discouraged' in 'they called her "Mama Awa", a name she neither encouraged nor discouraged'?
    Answer
    The phrase tells us that she did not promote the name herself but did not refuse it either. The framing is precise: she did not perform humility by rejecting the name, and did not perform warmth by claiming it. The writer is showing us how she occupied an honorific that was given to her by others, without quite making it her own. The detail does small but exact characterisation.
Inference
  • Why does the article note, twice, that the white coat had been repaired three times by a tailor in the market?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the detail does small but precise work. It shows that her work was not hers alone — the tailor was part of the network of small services that kept the clinic running. It shows her practical relationship with money and material things; she did not replace what could be repaired. And it gives the reader a concrete image of her, in her clinic, in a coat that was both old and adequate. The detail is, in the obituary's restrained register, a small portrait.
  • Why did Dr Diallo send her daughter Mariama to receive the national medal in 2009?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the ceremony conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa. The detail is precise about her priorities — the work in front of her, with women she knew by name, mattered more than the formal honour. Sending Mariama, the only one of her children who is not a doctor, is also worth noting; the article does not draw attention to the symmetry, but it allows the reader to see it.
  • Why does Dr Camara end his memory of her teaching with 'Wait for the second thing'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the second thing the patient says is, in his account, where the more important information often lies. The first thing is the easy version — the headline, the opening complaint. The second thing is what the patient is actually worried about, but does not say first. Dr Diallo's teaching, in his account, is about creating the conditions in which the second thing can emerge. The detail is small but is also, on inspection, a piece of clinical philosophy.
Discussion
  • Awa Diallo could have stayed in the capital with a much larger salary and a wider professional life. Was she right to return to Mansa, or was the choice itself a particular kind of privilege — the privilege of doing work that history will remember?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — Mansa needed a doctor; the work she did locally cannot be valued only by what it cost her. PARTICULAR PRIVILEGE — choosing to be remembered for one's commitment is itself a kind of luxury available to those who have already been chosen for medical school. PROBABLY BOTH — the choice was real, the cost was real, and the particular kind of significance the choice carries is also real. A useful question.
  • The article tells us that Dr Diallo was made an honorary fellow but that the certificate hung in the room where files were stored. Was this gesture humility, indifference, or something else?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. HUMILITY — she did not want to display her own importance to her patients. INDIFFERENCE — she did not, in fact, care much about the certificate. PRACTICAL — wall space in a clinic is for clinical posters, not for personal honours. PROBABLY ALL THREE — and the article does not require us to choose. A useful question about the various forms in which a self-effacing public manner can take shape.
  • The article ends with Dr Camara's claim that her continuing will take the form of the clinic, the village health workers, and the doctors she trained. Is this a true continuing, or is it a way of softening loss?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. TRUE — these are real institutions whose existence depends on the work she did; her continuing in them is not metaphorical. SOFTENING — the woman herself is gone; describing her continuing in institutions can be a way of avoiding the loss. PROBABLY BOTH — the institutions are real and the loss is real, and a mature account holds both. A useful question about what we mean by saying someone 'lives on'.
Personal
  • Has anyone in your family or community made a similar kind of decision — to take their work back to the place they came from, or to stay where the need was greatest? What did the choice cost, and what did it produce?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My uncle, a teacher, returned to our village from the city'; 'A nurse in our family stayed where she grew up though she could have gone elsewhere'; 'My grandmother stayed on a small farm when others left'; 'No, my family has mostly moved to where the work was'. Be warm. The question often surfaces real material.
  • Dr Camara says: 'She taught me how to listen to a patient.' Is there a person in your life who taught you how to listen — to a friend, a student, a parent, a customer? What did they teach you?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My grandmother who never interrupted'; 'A teacher who waited for me to find the words'; 'A friend who taught me to ask one more question'; 'I am still learning'. Be warm. The question is reflective and often produces real, small material.
Writing Task
Prompt
Write a short obituary (250–300 words) for a fictional person you can imagine clearly — a teacher, a mechanic, a village leader, a small-business owner. Open with a paragraph that gives the most important facts. Include: at least one quotation from a family member, one from a colleague or pupil, and one detail that makes the person specific (a saying, a habit, a piece of clothing, a notebook). End on a sentence that registers the life as a whole without overstating it. Use past simple, past perfect, and reported speech.
Model Answer

Mr Salim Park, who repaired bicycles in the village of Bardiya for forty-five years and refused to charge children for any work that took him less than an hour, died at his home on Tuesday. He was eighty-one. He had been ill for several months but had continued to receive bicycles, in a reduced way, until July of this year.

Mr Park was born in Bardiya in 1944. His father had been a carpenter; his older brother had been a soldier who did not return. Salim trained as a mechanic in the regional capital and returned to the village in 1965, opening a small workshop in a corner of his father's old yard. The workshop had a single tool bench, three crates of parts, and a sign in his own handwriting that read, simply, 'Salim, bicycles.'

For most of his working life, he was the only mechanic for twelve villages. "He fixed my mother's bicycle when she was a girl," Mrs Hadiya Khan, a former primary-school teacher, recalled. "He fixed mine. He fixed my children's. He pretended he was charging us, but he was usually not."

He married Mrs Aishe Park in 1970. They had three children. His son, Mr Tarek Park, has continued the workshop since 2018; the sign has been repainted but reads the same.

Mr Park is survived by his wife, his three children, and eight grandchildren. The funeral will be held at the village mosque on Friday morning. The workshop has been closed since Tuesday and will reopen on Monday. "He did not consider what he did to be remarkable," Mr Tarek Park said. "That, my father would say, was the whole point."

Activities
  • Quote analysis: in pairs, students take each direct quotation and discuss what it adds. Why does the obituary need each one?
  • Time order: in groups, students draw a timeline from 1941 (born) to last Sunday (died), marking the date and event for each thing the article mentions.
  • Detail map: in pairs, students list every concrete detail (the hardcover notebook, the white coat, the herbs, the documentary, the framed certificate) and discuss what each contributes to our picture of her.
  • Role-play: in groups of three, one student is Dr Camara, one is Awa's daughter Aissatou, one is a journalist. The journalist asks each what they would like people to remember.
  • Tone comparison: in pairs, students rewrite one paragraph in the style of (a) a national newspaper, (b) a small medical journal, (c) a village radio bulletin. Discuss what each gains and loses.
  • Vocabulary in context: in small groups, students choose six vocabulary items and write a paragraph using all of them, on a different fictional life.
  • Cultural sharing: in groups, students compare how their cultures remember a person who has died. Public ceremonies? Private gatherings? Songs? Newspaper notices?
  • Sentence frames: 'She was the first ___ from ___ to ___.' 'A name she neither encouraged nor discouraged.' 'There will be no ___ like her. That is the truth. But there will be ___.' Each student writes three sentences using these frames.
  • Compare with B2: in pairs, students read the same paragraph at B1 and B2 and identify three places where the B2 takes a stronger stance, holds two views at once, or uses more careful nominalisation.
Duration: 45 min 🎯 Focus: Complex subordination. Nominalisation (the qualification, the return, the framework, the recognition). Hedged claims. Cohesion devices: nevertheless, in turn, by contrast. Implicit author voice; a stance gently maintained. Free indirect style for institutional voices.
Before You Read / Listen
  • Q1Obituaries of distinguished women in the global south have, over the last twenty years, become a more visible presence in serious newspapers — partly because the women themselves have become more visible, and partly because the form of the obituary itself has been re-examined. What might both shifts owe to each other?
  • Q2There is a particular kind of life — long, locally based, structurally significant — that is hard to fit into the standard obituary template. The template tends to favour public events, awards, and dramatic firsts; the life tends to consist of decades of unremarkable presence in a small place. How does an obituary writer handle the difficulty?
  • Q3Many remarkable individual achievements in twentieth-century medicine were made possible by structural conditions — newly available medical schools, post-independence governments interested in primary care, vaccination programmes funded internationally. How should an honest obituary balance individual praise with structural acknowledgement?
  • Q4There is a difference between an obituary that praises a person and one that lets the person be seen. What distinguishes the two, and which kind would the subject themselves usually prefer?
  • Q5Communities that have been served by one person for over fifty years often develop a way of speaking about that person that an outsider — including a national newspaper — cannot easily reproduce. What is at stake when that person's death enters print?
The Text
Dr Awa Diallo, who was one of the first ten women in our country to qualify as a doctor and who, for fifty-one years, ran a small primary care clinic in her home town of Mansa while also helping, in the 1980s, to design the national child-health framework that became the basis of policy for the next two decades, died at her home on Sunday morning, surrounded by her family. She was eighty-four. She had been ill for several months but had continued to see patients, in a reduced way, until February of this year.
Awa Diallo was born on 14 March 1941, in a small house on the edge of the market in Mansa, a town of approximately twelve thousand people in the south of the country. Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher; her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader who employed, at any one time, between two and four other women. Awa was the third of seven children, and the only daughter for the first nine years of her life. "She used to say that being the only girl was the best preparation for everything that came afterwards," her younger brother, Mr Boubacar Diallo, recalled this week. "She did not mean it was lonely. She meant that she had had to argue early."
The choice to send her past primary school was not, in 1953, an obvious one. The first three uncles approached for support — including the eldest, who was, in conventional terms, expected to provide leadership on questions of family resources — declined. Two more were approached, and one of them agreed. The combination of his contribution, her father's small savings, and her mother's stitched assistance from the market was enough. "My father did not have many fights," her brother said. "He had this fight. He had it for two years. He won, although what he won was not, at first, very visible. What he won was that his daughter went to school. The visible part came later."
She qualified in medicine in 1968, at the age of twenty-six, from the country's then-only medical school. Of the forty-three students in her year, four were women. Two of those four left medicine within ten years for reasons that, in the social conditions of the time, do not bear simple description. One became a hospital director in another country. Only Awa Diallo, of the four, went to a small place and stayed. "She used to say that staying was harder than the leaving," Dr Aissatou Bah, her eldest daughter and herself a doctor, said this week. "She did not mean it as a complaint. She meant something more precise: that the work of building something is harder than people think, and the work of staying with what you have built, year after year, when novelty has gone and the difficulty has not, is harder still."
She returned to Mansa in November 1968. There had been no doctor in the town for the previous twelve years; the nearest hospital was eighty kilometres away on a road that, in the rains, was sometimes impassable for three or four days at a stretch. With a small loan from a community fund, and a building that her father helped her rent next to the market, she opened a clinic with three rooms — one for consultations, one for examinations, and one in which a single bed allowed her, in emergencies, to keep a patient overnight. She kept herbs in a small garden behind the building. She kept, in a hardcover notebook, a list of the families of every patient she saw. She kept the same kind of notebook, with the same kind of list, until 2019. The earliest of the notebooks, twenty-six in total, are now in the archive of the regional medical association.
For fifty-one years, Dr Diallo worked at this clinic. The work changed in many ways. The list of medicines available to her grew, as did the country's pharmaceutical infrastructure; the long-acting injectable contraceptives that became available in the mid-1980s shifted the texture of what was possible in a single consultation; vaccination programmes arrived, and her clinic was, in the late 1970s, one of the first in the region to offer the new childhood vaccination schedule. The roads to the surrounding villages were, in the 1990s, finally paved; the journey to Tola, which had taken her two and a half hours on foot in 1971, took thirty-five minutes by car in 2001. Some things did not change. The hardcover notebooks remained. The white coat, which she had been given as a graduation present by her uncle Boubacar — the second uncle, the one who said yes — was repaired three times by a tailor in the market and was still in use in 2018. She knew the name of every village health worker she had trained, and the names of their parents, and, in many cases, the names of their children.
In 1972, she married Mr Ibrahima Bah, an engineer who worked for the regional water authority and whom she had met at the wedding of a mutual cousin. They had four children, three of whom — Aissatou, Ibrahim, and Salimatou — are now doctors, and one of whom, Mariama, is a primary school teacher. Friends close to the family say that Dr Diallo was particularly clear, throughout her children's adolescence, that she did not want any of them to be doctors out of a sense of duty to her. "She told us we should choose what we wanted," Dr Aissatou Bah said. "She told us that being a doctor was hard, that it was sometimes lonely, that it should not be entered without thought. Three of us chose it anyway. Mariama did not. My mother used to say that of the four of us, Mariama was the one who had listened most carefully. I think that is partly true and partly the kind of remark that families learn to repeat. Mariama was, by any reasonable measure, the most carefully listened-to of us all."
From 1981 to 1990, she served as a senior adviser on child health to the Ministry of Health. She had agreed to accept the post on one condition: that she could continue to run her clinic in Mansa. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings, for nine years. The plan she helped to draft — a primary care framework that emphasised vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, antenatal monitoring, and the training of village health workers — became the basis of the national strategy until the early 2000s, and is widely thought, by those who study these things, to have saved a substantial number of children's lives. To say that the framework was hers alone would be to misrepresent the work; she would have been the first to say so. To say that it was not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth. The framework was the result of a particular collaboration, made possible by a particular government, in a particular decade; she was at the centre of it, and she was not the whole of it. Both descriptions are needed.
She was, throughout her life, less interested in the formal recognition of her work than in the work itself. She received the national medal for service in 2009; she did not, by all accounts, attend the ceremony, sending her daughter Mariama in her place because the date conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa. She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014; the certificate hung, framed, on the wall of the clinic, but in the room used for storing files, where most patients did not see it. She gave one extended interview to a documentary team, in 2018, on the condition that the team also spoke at length with three of the village health workers she had trained, and that the resulting film be shown first in Mansa and only then sent to film festivals. The film, on inspection, includes long sections in which Dr Diallo is silent and the health workers speak; this was, those involved have said, in keeping with her conditions, but it was also, on close watching, a piece of unobtrusive reorganisation of who is allowed to be the centre of attention in such a film. The reorganisation was, by her standards, characteristic.
Dozens of doctors in our country today were trained, in the final year of their medical education, at her clinic. Some of them lived in her house during their rural posting. They called her "Mama Awa", a name she neither encouraged nor discouraged. Dr Sory Camara, who is now in charge of the clinic together with her son Dr Ibrahim Bah, was one of those students. "She taught me how to listen to a patient," he said. "She would say: 'Sit down. Do not be in a hurry. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing. The first thing they say is the easiest thing. Wait for the second thing.' I have been a doctor for nineteen years. She was, on the central things, always right; on a small number of less central things, she was sometimes wrong. The capacity to be wrong about the small things while being right about the large was, I now think, a substantial part of what she had to teach."
The clinic, which has been closed since Sunday, will reopen on Wednesday. Dr Ibrahim Bah and Dr Sory Camara will continue the work. The village health workers — eleven of whom are still in active service across the surrounding fourteen villages, and several more of whom have themselves taught the next generation — will continue theirs. The notebooks, which Dr Diallo's family has agreed to make available to medical historians from 2030 onwards, will continue to exist. "There will be no doctor like her," Dr Camara said. "That is the truth. But there will be the clinic, and there will be the village health workers, and there will be the doctors she trained, several of whom are now training their own. That is the form her continuing will take, and it is, I think, the form she would have chosen."
Dr Diallo's husband, Mr Bah, died in 2018. She is survived by her four children, twelve grandchildren, and three great-grandchildren. The funeral will be held in Mansa on Friday morning. A memorial service for her colleagues and former students will be held at the regional medical association in the capital on the following Saturday. The family has asked, in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme that has, in various forms, continued since the early 1980s, and that bears, in its current form, the name she gave it on its founding: Tanto, which in the local language means, approximately, 'go and look.'
Key Vocabulary
self-effacement noun
the practice of avoiding drawing attention to oneself; modesty taken as a settled habit
"A kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth."
to misrepresent verb
to give a false or inaccurate description of something
"To say that the framework was hers alone would be to misrepresent the work."
in lieu of phrase
instead of; in place of (used especially in formal notices, often around funerals)
"The family has asked, in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme."
infrastructure (pharmaceutical infrastructure) noun
the basic physical and organisational structures needed for the operation of a society or service
"The country's pharmaceutical infrastructure."
long-acting injectable noun phrase
(of a medicine) given by injection and effective for an extended period
"The long-acting injectable contraceptives that became available in the mid-1980s."
characteristic (a characteristic move) adjective / noun
(adjective) typical of a particular person or thing / (noun) a feature that is typical
"The reorganisation was, by her standards, characteristic."
unobtrusive adjective
not noticeable; not drawing attention to itself
"An unobtrusive reorganisation of who is allowed to be the centre of attention."
substantial adjective
considerable in size, importance, or worth
"A substantial part of what she had to teach."
antenatal monitoring noun phrase
regular medical observation of women during pregnancy
"Vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, antenatal monitoring."
to bear (a name, a description) verb
to have or carry a particular name or description
"The programme that bears, in its current form, the name she gave it."
approximately adverb
roughly; close to but not exactly
"Tanto, which in the local language means, approximately, 'go and look.'"
by any reasonable measure phrase
according to any standard a sensible person would use
"Mariama was, by any reasonable measure, the most carefully listened-to of us all."
Questions
Comprehension
  • What does the article say about how the decision to send Awa past primary school was made?
    Answer
    The first three uncles approached — including the eldest, who was conventionally expected to lead on family resources — declined. Two more were approached, and one of them agreed. The combination of his contribution, her father's small savings, and her mother's stitched assistance from the market was enough. The article notes that her father had this fight for two years and won, although what he won was not, at first, very visible.
  • What does the article say about the four women in Awa's medical school year, and about her decision to return to Mansa?
    Answer
    Of forty-three students, four were women. Two left medicine within ten years for reasons that, in the social conditions of the time, do not bear simple description. One became a hospital director in another country. Only Awa Diallo, of the four, went to a small place and stayed. Her daughter says her mother used to say staying was harder than leaving, meaning the work of building something is hard, and the work of staying with what one has built — year after year, after novelty has gone and difficulty has not — is harder.
  • What does the article say about the changes the work underwent over fifty-one years, and what did not change?
    Answer
    The list of medicines grew with the country's pharmaceutical infrastructure; long-acting injectable contraceptives shifted what was possible in a single consultation; vaccination programmes arrived. Roads were paved in the 1990s; the journey to Tola, which had taken her two and a half hours on foot in 1971, took thirty-five minutes by car in 2001. The notebooks remained. The white coat, given to her by her uncle Boubacar — the second uncle, the one who said yes — was repaired three times by a tailor in the market and was still in use in 2018. She knew the name of every village health worker she had trained, and the names of their parents and often their children.
  • What does the article say about her contribution to the national framework, and about the question of how to credit it?
    Answer
    The framework, drafted between 1981 and 1990, emphasised vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, antenatal monitoring, and the training of village health workers. It became the basis of national strategy until the early 2000s and is widely thought to have saved a substantial number of children's lives. The writer says that to call the framework hers alone would be to misrepresent the work — she would have been the first to say so — but to say it was not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a self-effacement that had nothing to do with the underlying truth. Both descriptions are needed.
  • What does the article say about her response to formal recognition?
    Answer
    She received the national medal for service in 2009 but did not attend, sending her daughter Mariama in her place because of an antenatal clinic conflict. She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014; the framed certificate hung in the room where files were stored. She gave one documentary interview in 2018, on the condition that three of the village health workers she had trained were also interviewed at length and the film be shown first in Mansa. The film includes long sections in which she is silent and the health workers speak.
  • What does the article say about the form her continuing will take?
    Answer
    There will be no doctor like her — that is the truth. There will be the clinic; the village health workers (eleven still in active service across fourteen villages, several of whom have themselves taught the next generation); the doctors she trained, several of whom are now training their own. The notebooks will be available to medical historians from 2030. The family has asked that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme she founded in the early 1980s, which bears the name Tanto — meaning, approximately, 'go and look.'
Vocabulary
  • What is the rhetorical work of 'self-effacement' in 'a kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth'?
    Answer
    The phrase allows the writer to register her modest manner without letting that manner determine the description of the work. The writer is saying: she really was self-effacing, and that is part of who she was; but the work was nevertheless centrally hers, and her preference not to claim credit does not change the historical fact. The phrase does precise double work — honouring her temperament while preserving the accuracy of the description.
  • What does the writer mean by 'unobtrusive reorganisation' in 'an unobtrusive reorganisation of who is allowed to be the centre of attention'?
    Answer
    The phrase names a particular kind of intervention. By insisting that the documentary film also include the village health workers, and that long sections feature them rather than her, Dr Diallo arranged the film so that the standard centre — the distinguished doctor — was shared. This arrangement was not loud; it did not make itself the subject. The writer is calling attention to the act precisely because she did not.
  • What is the writer doing with 'do not bear simple description' in 'reasons that, in the social conditions of the time, do not bear simple description'?
    Answer
    The phrase is a careful evasion that is also a careful naming. The writer signals that the reasons two of the four women left medicine were complicated, probably gendered, probably unfair, and not the kind of thing that can be reduced to a single phrase in an obituary. The phrase respects the dead colleagues without flattening their stories, and respects the reader by not pretending the reasons were simply individual.
  • What does 'in lieu of' mean, and why is its use here characteristic of the obituary form?
    Answer
    It means 'instead of; in place of' and is a formal phrase used especially in funeral notices. Its appearance here — 'in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme' — is part of the conventional formal register the obituary inherits. The phrase places the family's request inside the recognised structure of public mourning, where it can be acted on by readers who know what they are being asked to do.
Inference
  • Why does the article note, when introducing the white coat, that the uncle who gave it was 'the second uncle, the one who said yes'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the detail closes a small loop. Earlier in the article, the second uncle is the one who agreed to contribute to her secondary school fees. Decades later, his graduation gift becomes the white coat she would wear for fifty years. The article is letting the reader notice — without making a fuss — that her career was made possible by particular individuals and that she did not forget who they were. The detail does precise structural work.
  • Why does Dr Aissatou Bah complicate her own remark about her sister Mariama, saying 'I think that is partly true and partly the kind of remark that families learn to repeat'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because she is doing two things at once. She is honouring her mother's saying — which the family has come to repeat about Mariama — while also signalling that the saying is not the whole truth. The remark is more interesting for the qualification: families develop sayings about each member, and the sayings are partly accurate and partly performative. Aissatou is, on close inspection, also saying something about how families remember themselves, and the writer has chosen to leave her qualification in the article rather than smooth it out.
  • Why does Dr Camara say that being wrong about the small things while being right about the large was 'a substantial part of what she had to teach'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the proportion is the lesson. Many doctors are right on details and wrong on the structure of care; many are confidently right where they are clearly visible, and never test themselves on the harder questions. To be reliably right on the central matters — when to wait, when to act, what really matters in a consultation — while being open to being wrong on the small ones is a particular kind of clinical and personal balance. Dr Camara is saying that watching her hold this balance was, more than any specific instruction, the teaching.
  • Why does the article close on the meaning of the word 'Tanto' rather than on Dr Diallo herself?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the closure does precise work. By ending on the name of the programme she founded, and on its translation — 'go and look' — the article hands the reader a small piece of her teaching practice, in her own language, that will continue. The translation is also, on inspection, a piece of clinical philosophy: the work begins not with knowing but with going and looking. The article ends on what she gave rather than on what was lost, but it ends on it in her own words, which is a more careful kind of ending.
Discussion
  • Was Awa Diallo right to return to Mansa, or did her return depend, in part, on a kind of structural support (her father's persistence, her uncle's contribution, the post-independence medical school, the government willing to consult her) that the obituary should foreground more?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — Mansa needed a doctor; the work she did locally is not diminished by structural conditions. STRUCTURAL — her individual achievement was made possible by particular conditions; an obituary that does not say so risks crediting heroism alone. PROBABLY BOTH — the article does, in fact, name several of the structural conditions; the question is whether the proportion is right. A useful question.
  • The writer holds open the question of how to credit the national child-health framework — neither entirely hers, nor not hers in any meaningful sense. Is this honesty, evasion, or the only honest position available?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. HONESTY — most significant institutional work is collaborative; pretending otherwise simplifies in misleading ways. EVASION — the article should be willing to assign credit, since failing to do so flattens the question. ONLY HONEST POSITION — the truth is that the framework was both her work and not hers alone; refusing to choose preserves both facts. PROBABLY THE LAST. A useful question about how obituaries should handle institutional contributions.
  • The film made about Dr Diallo includes long sections in which she is silent and the village health workers speak. Was this the right decision for the documentary, or does it tip from honest reframing into a different kind of self-presentation?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — sharing the centre of attention with the people whose work made hers possible is a real and honest reorganisation. SELF-PRESENTATION — choosing to be silent in a film about oneself is also a way of being present in a particular flattering way. PROBABLY BOTH — the act is real and the appearance is also calculated; mature understanding holds both. A useful question about the politics of representation.
  • What kinds of voices, perspectives, or experiences are missing from this obituary, and what might the absences tell us about the obituary form?
    Discussion prompts
    PRESENT: family (brother, daughter, son), colleague (Camara), patient by reference, village health workers by reference. ABSENT or UNDERREPRESENTED: patients themselves quoted directly; women who chose not to use her clinic and went elsewhere; the two women from her medical school year who left medicine; her husband Mr Bah's voice (he died in 2018); local critics or rivals; nurses and clinic staff; village health workers in their own voices, despite being mentioned; the eldest uncle who declined to contribute. The form gives voice to immediate family and to a senior colleague. A useful question.
  • What is the strongest critique of this obituary, given its evident respect for the subject?
    Discussion prompts
    Possible critiques: that the obituary is hagiographical despite its hedges; that it gives the family a curatorial control of the story that the writer has not fully named; that the closing detail about the word Tanto is too tidy and rhetorically polished; that the structural conditions for Dr Diallo's career are gestured at but not unpacked; that the form of the long obituary is itself a particular professional achievement that can sometimes prefer its own grace over the harder questions; that the absences (no patient quoted directly, no critic, no rival) are not simply omissions but are part of the form's habits. A useful question.
Personal
  • Has anyone in your life chosen to do work in their home community that they could have done elsewhere with more recognition? What did the choice cost, and what did it produce?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My uncle returned to teach in our village school'; 'A doctor from our town who came back from training abroad'; 'A craftsman who chose his home rather than the city'; 'My mother who stayed close to her own mother'; 'No, my family has mostly moved'. Be warm. The question often produces real material.
  • Dr Diallo's teaching focused on listening — on waiting for 'the second thing' the patient says. Is there a kind of listening you have learnt from someone, or that you are still learning? What is hard about it?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'Listening to my mother without arguing back'; 'Listening to a child who is upset; the words come slowly'; 'Listening to a colleague before offering advice'; 'I am still learning all of this'. Be warm. The question is reflective and may produce real material about practical attention.
Writing Task
Prompt
Write an obituary (450–550 words) for a fictional person whose life would deserve serious treatment in a regional or national newspaper — a teacher, a midwife, a community organiser, a small-business founder. Open with a paragraph that gives the most important facts. Use at least three quoted voices: a family member, a colleague or pupil, and someone whose presence is unexpected. Include at least one paragraph that names a structural condition (a medical school that opened just in time, a road that was finally paved, a government willing to consult, a community fund that lent the seed money). Hold open at least one question of credit or interpretation. End on something specific and quiet — a word, an object, a habit — rather than on a summary statement.
Model Answer

Mrs Hadiya Khan, who taught primary school in the village of Bardiya for forty-two years and who, by the time of her retirement in 2000, had taught at least one child from every household in the village, died at her home on Tuesday. She was eighty-six.

Mrs Khan was born in Bardiya in 1939, in a small house near the school where she would later teach. Her father had been a small-scale farmer; her mother had been a seamstress who, by working through five winters, paid for the school books that allowed Hadiya to finish primary school at a time when very few girls in the region did so. The teacher-training college in the regional capital opened, conveniently for her biography, in 1955; she was admitted in its third year of operation. "My mother used to say that her career was made possible by a college that opened just in time," her son, Mr Tarek Khan, said this week. "She did not consider this a sentimental observation. She considered it accurate."

She returned to Bardiya in 1958, when the school had one classroom, one teacher who was about to retire, and forty-seven pupils. By the time she retired, the school had six classrooms, four teachers, and over two hundred pupils. The growth was not, of course, hers alone — the village population had also grown; a regional government literacy programme of the 1970s had increased enrolment; the road that had been paved in 1981 had made it easier for older pupils to attend. To call the school's growth her achievement would be to misrepresent the work. To call it not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a kind of modesty that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth.

Mr Salim Park, a farmer and former pupil, said: "She taught my mother. She taught me. She taught my children. We did not always like her — she was strict — but we always trusted her. She had a way of looking at you when you had not done your homework that I can still feel."

Mrs Khan was made an honorary member of the regional teachers' association in 2010. The certificate, which arrived by post, was placed on the small table next to the door of her house, on top of a pile of receipts; her family says it remained there until she moved into her son's household two years before her death.

Mrs Khan is survived by her husband, three children, and seven grandchildren. The funeral will be held at the village mosque on Friday morning. The school has given the children a half-day off and has set out, in front of the main classroom, the small wooden chair on which she sat for thirty-eight years of her career. The chair will be returned to the classroom on Monday. "It is the right place for it," Mr Tarek Khan said.

Activities
  • Voice analysis: in pairs, students mark every sentence in which the writer's voice — not a quoted speaker — makes a small judgement (e.g. 'a kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth'). Discuss how a serious newspaper allows a writer to do this in an obituary.
  • Quotation mapping: in groups, students list every quoted person and what each contributes (brother, daughter, son, colleague). Discuss why the obituary needs all of them.
  • Hedge hunt: students find every careful or hedged claim ('approximately', 'by all accounts', 'on inspection', 'by any reasonable measure', 'in many cases'). Discuss what hedging achieves in serious obituary writing.
  • Structural conditions: in pairs, students list the structural conditions the article names (the medical school, the post-independence government, the community fund, the roads, the pharmaceutical infrastructure, the framework, the regional medical association). Discuss what changes in our picture of her achievement when these are foregrounded.
  • Detail map: in groups, students list every concrete detail in the article (the herbs, the white coat, the notebooks, the framed certificate, the documentary, the chair-equivalent of Tanto). Discuss what each contributes.
  • Reframing: in groups, students rewrite one paragraph from a different position (a national hagiographical eulogy; a critical academic essay on women in twentieth-century medicine; a village radio bulletin in plain prose). Discuss what each can and cannot say.
  • Cultural sharing: in groups, students compare obituary practices across their cultures. What is published? What is spoken? What is sung? What is private?
  • Sentence frames: 'To say that ___ would be to misrepresent the work; she would have been the first to say so. To say that it was not ___ in any meaningful sense would be to flatter ___ that had nothing to do with the underlying truth.' 'A name she neither encouraged nor discouraged.' 'There will be no ___ like her. That is the truth. But there will be ___.' Each student writes three sentences using these frames.
  • Compare with C1: in pairs, students read the same paragraph at B2 and C1 and identify three places where C1 takes the analysis further — usually by holding two positions at once, by reflecting on the form of the obituary itself, or by widening the historical or political frame.
Duration: 50 min 🎯 Focus: Extended argument with concession (however, nevertheless, granted that, and yet). Hedged generalisation (most obituaries, in the relevant tradition, with some justice). Cultural and political framing made explicit. Periodic sentences. Free indirect style for institutional voices. Sustained meditation on how to write a life.
Before You Read / Listen
  • Q1There is a particular kind of long obituary that the serious newspapers have refined over the last century — patient, balanced, slightly elegiac, ending often on a small specific image. The form is not stupid; it has been developed by good writers covering significant lives. What does it make easy to see, and what does it now leave unaddressed?
  • Q2The obituary as a published genre carries a particular relationship between the writer, the subject's family, and the institutions that have surrounded the subject's life. Most obituaries do not declare this relationship. What is gained, and what is lost, by declaring it?
  • Q3Many remarkable women in the post-independence global south combined household life, locally based professional work, and intermittent national-level service. The standard biographical template — single-track career, public achievements, climactic moments — does not fit such a life well. What does an honest obituary do with the mismatch?
  • Q4There is a difference between honouring a person and accurately describing them. Most published obituaries do both, in shifting proportions. Where does the proportion in this article sit, and is it the right one?
  • Q5Communities served by one figure for over fifty years often develop a way of speaking about that person that is rich, layered, and not easily reproducible in print. What is the obituary writer's responsibility when their version of the person enters circulation alongside the community's?
The Text
Dr Awa Diallo, who was one of the first ten women in our country to qualify as a doctor and who, for fifty-one years, ran a small primary care clinic in her home town of Mansa while also helping, in the 1980s, to design the national child-health framework that became the basis of policy for the next two decades, died at her home on Sunday morning, surrounded by her family. She was eighty-four. She had been ill for several months but had continued to see patients, in a reduced way, until February of this year. The obituary that follows is, by the standards of the genre, long. It will spend a substantial portion of its length on the daily texture of a clinical practice in a small town, partly because the practice was, by any reasonable standard, the central work of her life, and partly because the standard obituary form — which favours public achievements, structural firsts, and dramatic moments — does not, on inspection, fit a life of the kind she lived without distortion.
Awa Diallo was born on 14 March 1941, in a small house on the edge of the market in Mansa, a town of approximately twelve thousand people in the south of the country. Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher whose own father had been a religious teacher of modest local standing; her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader who employed, at any one time, between two and four other women, several of them widows. Awa was the third of seven children, and the only daughter for the first nine years of her life. "She used to say that being the only girl was the best preparation for everything that came afterwards," her younger brother, Mr Boubacar Diallo, recalled this week. "She did not mean it was lonely. She meant that she had had to argue early." The remark has been sharpened, over the decades, by family use; it is the kind of saying that families develop about their members, and that becomes, in time, neither quite a quotation nor quite a description but a useful shared phrase. The article, in citing it, is repeating a phrase that has already been used by people who knew her better than the writer ever did. This is, by the standards of obituary writing, normal; it is also worth registering that it is the case.
The choice to send her past primary school was not, in 1953, an obvious one. The first three uncles approached for support — including the eldest, who was, in conventional terms, expected to provide leadership on questions of family resources — declined. Two more were approached, and one of them agreed. The combination of his contribution, her father's small savings, and her mother's stitched assistance from the market was enough. "My father did not have many fights," her brother said. "He had this fight. He had it for two years. He won, although what he won was not, at first, very visible. What he won was that his daughter went to school. The visible part came later." The article would like to register that, in many of the obituaries of distinguished women of this period and region that have appeared in the international and national press, the figure of the supportive father is given a particular kind of curatorial space — admiring, slightly idealised, in some cases overdoing the moral credit. This article does not, on close inspection, escape the convention. Mr Mamadou Diallo, who died in 1979 and who is, by all accounts, the kind of man it is easy to write well of, has been written well of here. The convention is not entirely wrong; he was, by all accounts, the kind of man it depicts. The convention does, however, tend to produce a particular shape of story, in which a single father's persistence stands in for the wider network of women — mother, sister-in-law, aunts, neighbours, the cloth-trade community — who also made the path possible. The article would prefer to register this rather than to claim it has cleanly avoided it.
She qualified in medicine in 1968, at the age of twenty-six, from the country's then-only medical school. Of the forty-three students in her year, four were women. Two of those four left medicine within ten years for reasons that, in the social conditions of the time, do not bear simple description; one of the two later wrote a careful published account of her decision, and the article would direct interested readers to that source rather than attempt to summarise it here. One of the four became a hospital director in another country; the fourth, Awa Diallo, went to a small place and stayed. "She used to say that staying was harder than the leaving," Dr Aissatou Bah, her eldest daughter, said this week. "She did not mean it as a complaint. She meant something more precise: that the work of building something is harder than people think, and the work of staying with what you have built, year after year, when novelty has gone and the difficulty has not, is harder still." The remark, like the one about being the only girl, has been used by the family before. The article, in repeating it, is doing what obituaries do. It is also, on inspection, accepting a version of her that the family has refined over years; the writer notes this rather than contesting it.
She returned to Mansa in November 1968. There had been no doctor in the town for the previous twelve years; the nearest hospital was eighty kilometres away on a road that, in the rains, was sometimes impassable for three or four days at a stretch. With a small loan from a community fund, and a building that her father helped her rent next to the market, she opened a clinic with three rooms — one for consultations, one for examinations, and one in which a single bed allowed her, in emergencies, to keep a patient overnight. She kept herbs in a small garden behind the building. She kept, in a hardcover notebook, a list of the families of every patient she saw. She kept the same kind of notebook, with the same kind of list, until 2019. The earliest of the notebooks, twenty-six in total, are now in the archive of the regional medical association. The notebooks were not, in any conventional sense, scientific records. They were lists, made and kept by hand, of who had been at the clinic, who their parents were, what they had come for, and what had been done. They were also, on inspection, the operating system of a small primary-care practice in a place where the formal pharmaceutical and bureaucratic infrastructure was thin. They were, in other words, infrastructure that one woman had constructed because the surrounding infrastructure was not adequate to the work. The notebooks are why the work continued through the political and economic turbulence of the next four decades. The article would prefer to give them, on this occasion, more attention than the standard obituary form allows.
For fifty-one years, Dr Diallo worked at this clinic. The work changed in many ways. The list of medicines available to her grew, as did the country's pharmaceutical infrastructure; the long-acting injectable contraceptives that became available in the mid-1980s shifted the texture of what was possible in a single consultation; vaccination programmes arrived, and her clinic was, in the late 1970s, one of the first in the region to offer the new childhood vaccination schedule. The roads to the surrounding villages were, in the 1990s, finally paved; the journey to Tola, which had taken her two and a half hours on foot in 1971, took thirty-five minutes by car in 2001. Some things did not change. The hardcover notebooks remained. The white coat, which she had been given as a graduation present by her uncle Boubacar — the second uncle, the one who said yes — was repaired three times by a tailor in the market and was still in use in 2018. She knew the name of every village health worker she had trained, and the names of their parents, and, in many cases, the names of their children. The article would like to note here, with some care, that giving the impression of a life of unbroken continuity is one of the things obituaries do, and that no life is, on close inspection, that continuous. There were difficult years; there were patients who died whom she did not, in retrospect, think she had served well; there were colleagues with whom she had professional disagreements that did not, in her own account, resolve cleanly. The family has not asked for these things to be excluded from the obituary. The article has, on inspection, mostly excluded them anyway, partly because the form prefers continuity, partly because writing about specific clinical disagreements would require more reporting than was available, and partly because some of those colleagues are still living. The exclusion is worth registering. The continuity is not the whole truth.
From 1981 to 1990, she served as a senior adviser on child health to the Ministry of Health. She had agreed to accept the post on one condition: that she could continue to run her clinic in Mansa. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings, for nine years. The plan she helped to draft — a primary care framework that emphasised vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, antenatal monitoring, and the training of village health workers — became the basis of the national strategy until the early 2000s, and is widely thought, by those who study these things, to have saved a substantial number of children's lives. The framework was not hers alone. It was the result of collaboration with three named co-authors, two unnamed working groups, two consecutive ministers, and a regional health planning team that drew on technical assistance from international agencies whose role in shaping the framework's emphases was, in the historical record, both substantial and sometimes contested. To say that the framework was hers alone would be to misrepresent the work; she would have been the first to say so. To say that it was not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth. The framework was the result of a particular collaboration, made possible by a particular government, in a particular decade, in which a particular woman from a small town with a particular history of clinical practice was at the centre of the drafting. The article would prefer to keep all four particulars in front of the reader at once.
She was, throughout her life, less interested in the formal recognition of her work than in the work itself. She received the national medal for service in 2009; she did not, by all accounts, attend the ceremony, sending her daughter Mariama in her place because the date conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa. She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014; the certificate hung, framed, on the wall of the clinic, but in the room used for storing files, where most patients did not see it. She gave one extended interview to a documentary team, in 2018, on the condition that the team also spoke at length with three of the village health workers she had trained, and that the resulting film be shown first in Mansa and only then sent to film festivals. The film, on inspection, includes long sections in which Dr Diallo is silent and the health workers speak; this was, those involved have said, in keeping with her conditions, but it was also, on close watching, a piece of unobtrusive reorganisation of who is allowed to be the centre of attention in such a film. The reorganisation was, by her standards, characteristic. It is also, on inspection, the kind of move that has become a recognisable feature of the obituaries and documentary portraits of distinguished women of her generation in many regions; one notices it because it is real, and one notices it also because it has come, over the last twenty years, to be one of the marks by which a life is recognised as exemplary. The film is, by any standard, a piece of generous self-presentation. The previous sentence is the kind of thing the obituary writer can say while still admiring her, and is the kind of thing the previous biographical paragraphs would not, on their own, have made room for.
Dozens of doctors in our country today were trained, in the final year of their medical education, at her clinic. Some of them lived in her house during their rural posting. They called her "Mama Awa", a name she neither encouraged nor discouraged. Dr Sory Camara, who is now in charge of the clinic together with her son Dr Ibrahim Bah, was one of those students. "She taught me how to listen to a patient," he said. "She would say: 'Sit down. Do not be in a hurry. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing. The first thing they say is the easiest thing. Wait for the second thing.' I have been a doctor for nineteen years. She was, on the central things, always right; on a small number of less central things, she was sometimes wrong. The capacity to be wrong about the small things while being right about the large was, I now think, a substantial part of what she had to teach." The remark is, on inspection, the most analytically generous thing said about her in this obituary, and it has been said by a younger man who has served in her clinic for more than nineteen years. The writer would prefer to leave it as the centre of the obituary, but is aware that the form prefers a different kind of structural climax — usually a final image, a closing line, an evocative detail. The article will provide one of those in due course; it is also worth noting, here, that the most accurate account of her may not be in the closing image but in the middle of the article, in a paragraph in which a colleague is allowed to be technical, slightly qualified, and unsentimental.
Dr Diallo's husband, Mr Bah, died in 2018. She is survived by her four children, twelve grandchildren, and three great-grandchildren. The funeral will be held in Mansa on Friday morning. A memorial service for her colleagues and former students will be held at the regional medical association in the capital on the following Saturday. The clinic, which has been closed since Sunday, will reopen on Wednesday. Dr Ibrahim Bah and Dr Sory Camara will continue the work. The village health workers — eleven of whom are still in active service across the surrounding fourteen villages, and several more of whom have themselves taught the next generation — will continue theirs. The notebooks, which Dr Diallo's family has agreed to make available to medical historians from 2030 onwards, will continue to exist. The family has asked, in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme that has, in various forms, continued since the early 1980s, and that bears, in its current form, the name she gave it on its founding: Tanto, which in the local language means, approximately, 'go and look.' The translation is conveniently apt; this is the kind of thing one notices about the names that distinguished people choose for the things they found, and it is also the kind of thing that a careful obituary writer should resist over-using. I am ending the article here, on the name and its translation, partly because the closing image is what the form expects, partly because the name is genuinely good, and partly because, after some hours of writing, ending elsewhere would feel like a refusal of a closing image that the obituary has earned. The article would prefer to register all three reasons, and to allow the reader to weigh them.
Key Vocabulary
curatorial space noun phrase
the space in a piece of writing devoted to a particular subject, especially when that space has been carefully arranged or shaped
"The figure of the supportive father is given a particular kind of curatorial space."
convention (a journalistic or literary convention) noun
a customary practice in writing, especially one followed without fresh reflection each time
"This article does not, on close inspection, escape the convention."
to flatter (a quality) verb
(here) to overstate or treat too generously a quality that is real but not as central as the treatment suggests
"Would be to flatter a kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth."
to register (a fact) verb
(in journalism) to acknowledge the existence of something, often without exploiting it
"The article would prefer to register this rather than to claim it has cleanly avoided it."
infrastructure (institutional) noun
the basic physical and organisational structures needed for the operation of a society or service; here, the structures Dr Diallo herself constructed
"Infrastructure that one woman had constructed because the surrounding infrastructure was not adequate."
exemplary adjective
serving as a desirable model; representing the best of its kind
"It has come, over the last twenty years, to be one of the marks by which a life is recognised as exemplary."
generous self-presentation noun phrase
(of a public figure) presenting oneself in a way that is genuinely modest and also strategically effective
"A piece of generous self-presentation."
structural climax noun phrase
the moment in a piece of writing where the form expects the highest emphasis or release of tension
"The form prefers a different kind of structural climax — usually a final image, a closing line, an evocative detail."
in lieu of phrase
instead of; in place of (used especially in formal notices, often around funerals)
"The family has asked, in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme."
conveniently apt phrase
fitting well in a way that the writer suspects is too neat to be entirely accidental
"The translation is conveniently apt."
self-effacement noun
the practice of avoiding drawing attention to oneself; modesty taken as a settled habit
"A kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth."
by all accounts phrase
according to what everyone says
"She did not, by all accounts, attend the ceremony."
by any reasonable standard phrase
according to any standard a sensible person would use
"The practice was, by any reasonable standard, the central work of her life."
Questions
Comprehension
  • What does the writer say the obituary will spend most of its length on, and why?
    Answer
    The daily texture of a clinical practice in a small town. Partly because the practice was, by any reasonable standard, the central work of her life, and partly because the standard obituary form — which favours public achievements, structural firsts, and dramatic moments — does not fit a life of the kind she lived without distortion.
  • What does the writer note about the saying 'being the only girl was the best preparation for everything that came afterwards'?
    Answer
    The remark has been sharpened, over the decades, by family use. It is the kind of saying that families develop about their members and that becomes, in time, neither quite a quotation nor quite a description but a useful shared phrase. The article, in citing it, is repeating a phrase that has already been used by people who knew her better than the writer ever did. This is, by the standards of obituary writing, normal; the writer registers that it is the case.
  • What does the writer note about the convention of the supportive father in obituaries of distinguished women of this period?
    Answer
    The figure is given a particular kind of curatorial space — admiring, slightly idealised, in some cases overdoing the moral credit. The article does not, on close inspection, escape the convention. Mr Mamadou Diallo has been written well of here, partly because he was, by all accounts, the kind of man it is easy to write well of, and partly because the convention does the work. The convention tends to produce a particular shape of story in which a single father's persistence stands in for a wider network of women who also made the path possible.
  • What does the writer say about Dr Diallo's notebooks?
    Answer
    The notebooks were lists, made and kept by hand, of who had been at the clinic, who their parents were, what they had come for, and what had been done. They were not, in any conventional sense, scientific records. They were the operating system of a small primary-care practice in a place where the formal pharmaceutical and bureaucratic infrastructure was thin. They were infrastructure that one woman had constructed because the surrounding infrastructure was not adequate. They are why the work continued through the political and economic turbulence of the next four decades.
  • What does the writer admit about the impression of continuity in the article?
    Answer
    Giving the impression of a life of unbroken continuity is one of the things obituaries do. No life is that continuous. There were difficult years, patients who died whom she did not think she had served well, colleagues with whom she had professional disagreements that did not resolve cleanly. The family has not asked for these to be excluded; the article has mostly excluded them anyway, partly because the form prefers continuity, partly because writing about specific clinical disagreements would require more reporting than was available, and partly because some of those colleagues are still living. The exclusion is worth registering.
  • What does the writer say about the credit for the national child-health framework?
    Answer
    It was the result of collaboration with three named co-authors, two unnamed working groups, two consecutive ministers, and a regional health planning team that drew on technical assistance from international agencies whose role was both substantial and sometimes contested. Saying it was hers alone would be to misrepresent. Saying it was not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a self-effacement that had nothing to do with the underlying truth. The framework was the result of a particular collaboration, made possible by a particular government, in a particular decade, in which a particular woman with a particular clinical history was at the centre of the drafting.
  • What does the writer say about the writer's choice of where to end the obituary?
    Answer
    The writer ends on the name 'Tanto' and its translation 'go and look', partly because the closing image is what the form expects, partly because the name is genuinely good, and partly because, after some hours of writing, ending elsewhere would feel like a refusal of a closing image the obituary has earned. The article registers all three reasons and allows the reader to weigh them.
Vocabulary
  • What is the rhetorical work of 'curatorial space' in the article's discussion of the supportive father?
    Answer
    The phrase characterises a particular kind of textual privilege. A curatorial space is not just space; it is space that has been arranged, framed, and lit for a particular kind of attention. By saying the figure of the supportive father is given a 'curatorial space' in obituaries of distinguished women of this period, the writer is naming a structural pattern in the genre, not just describing one obituary. The phrase allows the writer to make a precise critique of a convention while continuing to use the convention.
  • What does the writer mean by 'structural climax' in 'the form prefers a different kind of structural climax'?
    Answer
    A structural climax is the moment in a piece of writing where the form expects the highest emphasis or release of tension. In the obituary form, this is usually a final image, a closing line, or an evocative detail. The writer is naming the form's expectation in order to comment on it: the most analytically valuable moment in this obituary may not be the closing image but a paragraph in the middle, where a colleague speaks technically. The phrase allows the writer to honour Dr Camara's remark precisely by noting where it sits.
  • What is the writer doing with 'conveniently apt' in 'the translation is conveniently apt'?
    Answer
    The phrase is precise self-checking. The translation 'go and look' fits the article's themes too well — it suggests a piece of clinical philosophy, an instruction to the reader, a name carrying clinical weight. By calling the fit 'conveniently apt', the writer is signalling awareness that this is the kind of detail an obituary writer reaches for and might overuse. The phrase allows the writer to use the detail while admitting to its overdetermined quality. The honesty does not undo the use; it complicates it.
Inference
  • Why does the writer describe Dr Camara's remark as 'the most analytically generous thing said about her in this obituary'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because Dr Camara's remark is technical and slightly qualified — she was right on the central things, sometimes wrong on small ones, and the proportion was the lesson. This kind of generosity is harder than admiring claims of consistent rightness. It honours her by being accurate; it credits her by recognising her capacity to hold a particular balance. The writer wants the reader to see that real respect, in this register, is closer to Dr Camara's qualified version than to undivided praise.
  • Why does the writer say that the documentary's reorganisation of attention is 'the kind of move that has become a recognisable feature of the obituaries and documentary portraits of distinguished women of her generation'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the writer is registering, with care, that genuinely modest acts can also become recognisable conventions. Insisting that the spotlight be shared is real and admirable; it is also, over twenty years and many such portraits, a recognisable mark by which a life is judged exemplary. The writer is admitting two things at once: that the move is honourable in this case, and that the genre has come to expect it. Both can be true.
  • Why does the writer register, openly, three reasons for ending the article where it does?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the writer is being explicit about the construction of the closing. The form expects a closing image; the name is good; some hours of writing make a different ending feel forced. By naming all three reasons, the writer refuses the easier honesty (registering only one) and refuses the easier dishonesty (claiming the ending is purely natural). The reader is invited to weigh them. The honesty is part of the writer's authority; it is also, on inspection, a recognisable signature of long-form obituary writing in the present moment.
  • Why does the writer note that the family 'has not asked for these things to be excluded' but the article 'has, on inspection, mostly excluded them anyway'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the writer is being precise about responsibility. The exclusions are not the family's fault. They are the result of three things: the form's preference for continuity, the practical limits of available reporting, and consideration for living colleagues. By naming the chain of reasons, the writer does not blame the form, the family, or the reporting alone, and gives the reader an honest picture of how an obituary's smoothness is produced.
Discussion
  • Did Dr Diallo's life, as described, depend on a structural condition (the medical school, the post-independence government, the supportive uncle, the community fund) that obituaries of distinguished individuals tend to underemphasise? If so, what would an obituary that foregrounded the structural conditions look like?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. YES — individual achievement was made possible by particular conditions; foregrounding them produces a different kind of credit and a different lesson. NOT QUITE — the article does name several structural conditions; the question is whether the proportion is right. AN OBITUARY OF STRUCTURE WOULD foreground the medical school's history, the cohort of four women, the regional fund, the road, the framework's collaborators; it would risk dispersing the subject's individuality, and might be a different genre. PROBABLY THE ARTICLE IS PARTIAL — and naming the partiality is a reasonable response. A useful question.
  • The writer says the exclusion of difficult years and unresolved disagreements is 'worth registering' but proceeds with the exclusion anyway. Is this honest, evasive, or the only honest thing available?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. HONEST — naming the exclusion is more honest than pretending it is not happening; the practical reasons are real. EVASIVE — the article could have done more reporting and could have included a careful version of the disagreements; settling for naming the gap is convenient. ONLY HONEST POSITION — full reporting would require more access, time, and consent than was available; partial registration is the maximum available honesty. PROBABLY THE LAST OR A MIX. A useful question about practical ethics.
  • The article distinguishes Dr Camara's 'analytically generous' remark from undivided praise, and suggests it is the closest the obituary comes to the truth. Is this the right standard for obituaries — accurate qualification rather than wholehearted praise — or does it underestimate what obituaries are for?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — accuracy honours the dead more than enthusiasm; flattening someone into praise misses who they were. UNDERESTIMATES — obituaries also serve mourning, and emotional simplicity is part of their work; analytical qualification can feel cold. PROBABLY BOTH KINDS NEEDED — the qualified version is more accurate; the simpler version is what families and communities often need; mature publications can do both. A useful question about the form's purposes.
  • What kinds of voices, perspectives, or experiences are missing from this obituary, and what might the absences tell us about the form?
    Discussion prompts
    PRESENT: family (brother, daughter, son), colleague (Camara), the writer's voice. ABSENT or UNDERREPRESENTED: patients themselves quoted directly; women who chose not to use her clinic; the two women from her medical school year who left medicine; her husband Mr Bah's voice (he died in 2018); local critics or rivals; nurses and clinic staff in their own voices; village health workers in their own voices, despite being central; the eldest uncle who declined to contribute; the international agencies whose role is mentioned but not unpacked. The form gives voice to immediate family and to a senior colleague. A useful question.
  • What is the strongest critique of this obituary, given its evident respect for the subject and its self-aware framing?
    Discussion prompts
    Possible critiques: that the meta-commentary on the writer's own moves is itself a literary performance that buys credit for noticing; that the article is hagiographical despite its hedges; that the closing detail about Tanto is too tidy and rhetorically polished, and the writer's admission that it is 'conveniently apt' does not undo the choice; that the family has been allowed curatorial control of the narrative which the writer has named but not contested; that the structural conditions are gestured at but not unpacked; that admitting to using a convention while continuing to use it is a kind of plausible deniability; that the writer's voice has more space than would be standard, and that this voice does political work the article does not declare. A useful question.
Personal
  • Has anyone in your community made the kind of choice Dr Diallo made — to take their training back to a small place rather than to a wider stage? What did the choice cost, and what did it produce?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My uncle returned to teach in our village school'; 'A doctor from our town who came back from training abroad'; 'A craftsman who chose his home rather than the city'; 'My mother who stayed close to her own mother'; 'No, my family has mostly moved'. Be warm. The question often produces real material.
  • Dr Camara says the capacity to be wrong about small things while being right about the large was 'a substantial part of what she had to teach'. Is there a person in your life who has shown you something similar — a way of holding the proportion between large and small? What did you learn?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My grandmother — generous in matters that mattered, exacting about small habits'; 'A teacher who let small mistakes pass and was strict about ideas'; 'A friend who is wrong about small things but always right when it matters'; 'I am still working out the proportion in myself'. Be warm. The question is reflective.
Writing Task
Prompt
Write a long-form obituary (700–900 words) for a fictional figure who deserves serious treatment in a national newspaper — a doctor, a teacher, a craftsman, an organiser, a small-business founder. Open with a paragraph that gives the most important facts and signals what the obituary will and will not do. Use at least three quoted voices. Include at least one paragraph that reflects on the form of the obituary itself — a convention you are using, a gap you are leaving, a detail you are choosing to give weight to. Hold open at least one question of credit. Acknowledge at least one structural condition that made the life possible. End on something specific and quiet, and either name the reasons for ending there or let the ending stand without commentary, depending on what the life requires.
Model Answer

Mrs Hadiya Khan, who taught primary school in the village of Bardiya for forty-two years and who, by the time of her retirement in 2000, had taught at least one child from every household in the village, died at her home on Tuesday. She was eighty-six. The obituary that follows is, by the standards of the genre, long. It will spend a substantial portion of its length on the daily texture of a small village school, partly because the school was the central work of her life, and partly because the standard obituary form, which favours public events and dramatic firsts, does not fit a life of the kind she lived without distortion.

Mrs Khan was born in Bardiya in 1939, in a small house near the school where she would later teach. Her father had been a small-scale farmer; her mother had been a seamstress who, by working through five winters, paid for the school books that allowed Hadiya to finish primary school at a time when very few girls in the region did so. The teacher-training college in the regional capital opened, conveniently for her biography, in 1955; she was admitted in its third year of operation. The convenience is worth registering. The figure of the timely institution — opened just in time, with space for one more student — has become a recognisable feature of obituaries of distinguished women of her generation, and this obituary does not, on close inspection, escape the convention. The convention is not entirely wrong; the college did open in 1955, and it did make her career possible. The convention does, however, produce a particular shape of story in which the institution stands in for a wider history of policy, advocacy, and luck.

She returned to Bardiya in 1958, when the school had one classroom, one teacher who was about to retire, and forty-seven pupils. By the time she retired, the school had six classrooms, four teachers, and over two hundred pupils. The growth was not, of course, hers alone. The village population had grown; a regional government literacy programme of the 1970s had increased enrolment; the road that had been paved in 1981 had made it easier for older pupils to attend. To call the school's growth her achievement would be to misrepresent. To call it not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a kind of modesty that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth. The growth was the result of a particular set of conditions in which Mrs Khan was at the centre of the daily teaching for four decades.

Mr Salim Park, a farmer and former pupil, said: "She taught my mother. She taught me. She taught my children. We did not always like her — she was strict — but we always trusted her. She had a way of looking at you when you had not done your homework that I can still feel." The remark is, on inspection, the most analytically generous thing in this obituary. It does not pretend she was beloved by all; it admits she was strict; it locates her in the bodies of three generations who learnt under her gaze.

Mrs Khan was made an honorary member of the regional teachers' association in 2010. The certificate, which arrived by post, was placed on the small table next to the door of her house, on top of a pile of receipts; her family says it remained there until she moved into her son's household two years before her death.

The article would prefer to register that there were difficult years; there were pupils she did not, in retrospect, think she had served well; there were colleagues with whom she had disagreements that did not resolve cleanly. The article has, on inspection, mostly excluded these, partly because the form prefers continuity, partly because reporting them would require more access than was available, and partly because some of those colleagues are still living.

Mrs Khan is survived by her husband, three children, and seven grandchildren. The funeral will be held at the village mosque on Friday morning. The school has given the children a half-day off and has set out, in front of the main classroom, the small wooden chair on which she sat for thirty-eight years of her career. The chair will be returned to the classroom on Monday. "It is the right place for it," Mr Tarek Khan said. I am ending the article here, on the chair and its return, partly because the closing image is what the form expects, partly because the chair is genuinely good, and partly because, after some hours of writing, ending elsewhere would feel like a refusal of a closing image that the obituary has earned.

Activities
  • Voice and concession: in pairs, students mark every concession move in the article ('granted that', 'on the whole', 'and yet', 'in any meaningful sense'). Discuss how concession is the engine of measured argument in obituary writing.
  • Form awareness: in groups, students identify every place where the writer steps back to comment on the conventions of obituary writing. Discuss whether this strengthens or weakens the obituary.
  • Convention audit: in pairs, students take the writer's claim about the supportive father convention and apply it to other obituaries they know. They list other recognisable conventions (the timely institution, the modest closing detail, the rivalling colleague who praises generously).
  • Tracing a critique: in pairs, students take the question 'What is the strongest critique of this obituary?' and write a one-paragraph critique together, in the voice of a serious but generous reader.
  • Reframing: in groups, students rewrite one paragraph from a different position (a hagiographical eulogy in a village newsletter; a critical academic essay on women in twentieth-century medicine; a documentary film transcript). Discuss what each can and cannot say.
  • The exclusion question: in pairs, students discuss the writer's open admission that difficult years and unresolved disagreements have been mostly excluded. They list three other things obituaries typically exclude, and consider whether the exclusions can be honest.
  • Cohesion device close-reading: in pairs, students take a paragraph and remove all of the writer's hedging and concession devices. Read aloud both versions. Discuss what is gained and lost.
  • Cultural sharing: in groups, students compare how distinguished lives are remembered in obituary writing in their countries. What is emphasised? Whose voices appear? What is the tone?
  • Sentence frames: 'The obituary that follows is, by the standards of the genre, long.' 'To say that ___ would be to misrepresent the work; she would have been the first to say so. To say that it was not ___ in any meaningful sense would be to flatter ___ that had nothing to do with the underlying truth.' 'I am ending the article here, partly because ___, partly because ___, and partly because ___.' Each student writes three sentences using these frames.
  • Compare with C2: students read the same paragraph at C1 and C2 and identify three places where C2 takes the analysis further — by self-reflection, by irony, or by widening the historical or political frame.
  • Closing-paragraph debate: in pairs, students discuss whether the writer was right to name, explicitly, three reasons for ending where they do. Is this honest or self-indulgent? Defend both positions seriously.
Duration: 55 min 🎯 Focus: Periodic sentences. Philosophical register. Irony held alongside generosity. Self-aware metacommentary on the form of the obituary as a literary tradition. Refusal of resolution. Hedged generalisation about the practice of writing about the dead. Free indirect style for institutional voices. Sustained meditation on representation, credit, and the politics of remembrance, and on the writer's own implication in the form being analysed.
Before You Read / Listen
  • Q1There is a particular mode of long-form obituary writing that the broadsheet press has, over the last several decades, refined to a high degree of accomplishment — patient, balanced, selectively quoted, ending often on a small physical detail that does the work of summary by indirection. The mode is not stupid. It has been developed by careful writers covering serious lives. What does it make easy to see, and what does its very accomplishment now leave unaddressed?
  • Q2When a writer covers the death of a distinguished figure, they enter an arrangement with the family that includes negotiated quotations, agreed-upon silences, and shared understandings about what the obituary is for. Most obituaries do not declare this arrangement. What is gained, and what is lost, by declaring it?
  • Q3Obituaries of distinguished women in the global south, taken collectively over the last twenty years, have developed a recognisable shape — supportive father, timely institution, lonely cohort of one or two, return to a small place, decades of patient practice, modest response to recognition, closing image of a small physical object. Each element corresponds to something real in many such lives. What does the consolidation into a recognisable shape do to the form's capacity to register what is genuinely particular about any single life?
  • Q4Consider the figure of the obituary writer, who has perhaps two days to write up a life of eighty-four years, who knows the family will read the result, who is working for a paper whose obituary section has its own conventions, and who is also aware that the obituary is one piece in a much larger collective picture of distinguished women in twentieth-century medicine. What can such a writer reasonably hope to do, and what should they decline to attempt?
  • Q5There is a difference between an obituary that is honest about its conditions of production and an obituary that performs that honesty as a recognisable kind of authority. Long-form newspaper obituaries in the present moment increasingly do both. How does a reader, or a writer, tell them apart, and is the question more or less interesting than the life being remembered?
The Text
Dr Awa Diallo, who was one of the first ten women in our country to qualify as a doctor and who, for fifty-one years, ran a small primary care clinic in her home town of Mansa while also helping, in the 1980s, to design the national child-health framework that became the basis of policy for the next two decades, died at her home on Sunday morning, surrounded by her family. She was eighty-four. She had been ill for several months but had continued to see patients, in a reduced way, until February of this year. The obituary that follows is, by the standards of the genre, long. It will spend a substantial portion of its length not on the chronology of her life but on the conditions under which lives such as hers come to be written about, partly because those conditions are interesting in their own right and partly because the obituary that focuses primarily on the chronology has been written, very competently, several thousand times in the last forty years for women of broadly similar profiles, and one further such obituary will, on the most charitable assessment, contribute relatively little to the reader's understanding of either Dr Diallo herself or of the form into which she has been entered.
It is at this point in any obituary of this kind that the writer encounters a particular kind of pressure that the reader may, with some justice, want named. The pressure is not exactly to lie. The pressure is to use, without examining, a set of phrases — 'a trailblazer who never lost her humility', 'a woman who served her community with quiet distinction', 'a beacon for the women who followed her', 'her spirit will live on in the village she loved' — each of which has, in the present moment, become part of how lives such as hers are reported, and each of which, accumulating across thousands of obituaries over decades, has done a particular kind of cumulative work. The work is to convert a slow, structurally conditioned, often partial life of professional service in a complicated place into a sequence of moral parables. The cumulative effect, on the average reader of a regional or national newspaper's obituary section, is a picture of distinguished women in twentieth-century medicine in which individual virtue and patient organising tend to produce, on a roughly human timescale, more or less complete and recognisable lives, in which the role of changing infrastructure and of changing financial and political pressure is somewhat secondary, and in which the more accurate and less flattering picture — that such lives were partial, contingent, expensive in particular ways, often dependent on temporary alignments of policy and institutional interest, and frequently in tension with the people who later wrote about them — is, on the whole, not visible. I have written paragraphs containing some of these phrases. I have, in earlier years and on tighter deadlines, used several of them in the same obituary. I am not going to use them in this article. I am also not going to take credit for their absence as if it were a difficult discipline; it is, more accurately, the minimum that the obituary owes the reader and Dr Diallo, given that the obituary is being written for the kind of newspaper that ought, by its own standards, to know better.
Awa Diallo was born on 14 March 1941, in a small house on the edge of the market in Mansa, a town of approximately twelve thousand people in the south of the country. Her father, Mr Mamadou Diallo, was a primary school teacher whose own father had been a religious teacher of modest local standing; her mother, Mrs Adama Diallo, was a cloth trader who employed, at any one time, between two and four other women, several of them widows. Awa was the third of seven children, and the only daughter for the first nine years of her life. "She used to say that being the only girl was the best preparation for everything that came afterwards," her younger brother, Mr Boubacar Diallo, recalled this week. The remark, as the article would prefer to register, has been sharpened over the decades by family use; it is the kind of saying that families develop about their members and that becomes, in time, neither quite a quotation nor quite a description but a useful shared phrase. The article, in citing it, is repeating a phrase that has already been used by people who knew her better than the writer ever did. There is a particular trick the obituary will go on to perform throughout, which it would now be evasive not to name. The trick is the implicit suggestion that, by analysing the form of the obituary, the article is somehow standing outside it. The article is not standing outside it. The article is being written for the same newspaper that will run several other obituaries this week, in broadly the same register, by writers with broadly the same training. It is using, with adjustment, several of the same moves — the careful opening, the family quotation, the timely institution, the closing image of a small physical object that does the work of summary by indirection. The principal difference is that the article is naming the moves as it makes them. This is a smaller difference than the article occasionally implies, and the difference is, I think, worth real if not unlimited credit. It is also, on inspection, a recognisable signature of the kind of long obituary that has come to occupy the slow Sunday slots in serious newspapers over the last twenty years.
The choice to send her past primary school was not, in 1953, an obvious one. The first three uncles approached for support — including the eldest, who was, in conventional terms, expected to provide leadership on questions of family resources — declined. Two more were approached, and one of them agreed. The combination of his contribution, her father's small savings, and her mother's stitched assistance from the market was enough. "My father did not have many fights," her brother said. "He had this fight. He had it for two years. He won, although what he won was not, at first, very visible. What he won was that his daughter went to school. The visible part came later." The article would like to register, while the matter is in front of us, that the figure of the supportive father has, in obituaries of distinguished women of this period and region, been given a particular kind of curatorial space — admiring, slightly idealised, in some cases overdoing the moral credit. This article does not, on close inspection, escape the convention. Mr Mamadou Diallo, who died in 1979 and who is, by all accounts, the kind of man it is easy to write well of, has been written well of here. He was, by all accounts, the kind of man the convention depicts. The convention does, however, tend to produce a particular shape of story, in which a single father's persistence stands in for the wider network of women — mother, sister-in-law, aunts, neighbours, the cloth-trade community — who also made the path possible. The article would prefer to register this rather than to claim it has cleanly avoided it.
She qualified in medicine in 1968, at the age of twenty-six, from the country's then-only medical school. Of the forty-three students in her year, four were women. Two of those four left medicine within ten years for reasons that, in the social conditions of the time, do not bear simple description; one of the two later wrote a careful published account of her decision, and the article would direct interested readers to that source rather than attempt to summarise it here. One of the four became a hospital director in another country; the fourth, Awa Diallo, went to a small place and stayed. "She used to say that staying was harder than the leaving," Dr Aissatou Bah, her eldest daughter, said. "She did not mean it as a complaint. She meant something more precise: that the work of building something is harder than people think, and the work of staying with what you have built, year after year, when novelty has gone and the difficulty has not, is harder still." The remark, like the one about being the only girl, has been used by the family before. The article, in repeating it, is doing what obituaries do. It is also, on inspection, accepting a version of her that the family has refined over years; the writer notes this rather than contesting it.
She returned to Mansa in November 1968. There had been no doctor in the town for the previous twelve years; the nearest hospital was eighty kilometres away on a road that, in the rains, was sometimes impassable for three or four days at a stretch. With a small loan from a community fund, and a building that her father helped her rent next to the market, she opened a clinic with three rooms — one for consultations, one for examinations, and one in which a single bed allowed her, in emergencies, to keep a patient overnight. She kept herbs in a small garden behind the building. She kept, in a hardcover notebook, a list of the families of every patient she saw. She kept the same kind of notebook, with the same kind of list, until 2019. The earliest of the notebooks, twenty-six in total, are now in the archive of the regional medical association. The notebooks were not, in any conventional sense, scientific records. They were lists, made and kept by hand, of who had been at the clinic, who their parents were, what they had come for, and what had been done. They were also, on inspection, the operating system of a small primary-care practice in a place where the formal pharmaceutical and bureaucratic infrastructure was thin. They were, in other words, infrastructure that one woman had constructed because the surrounding infrastructure was not adequate to the work. The notebooks are why the work continued through the political and economic turbulence of the next four decades, and they are also, on inspection, the kind of artefact that obituaries of distinguished women of this generation have come to foreground in a particular way. The article would like to give them more attention than the standard form allows, while admitting that the attention itself is, in the present moment, a recognisable mode of attention. The notebooks are real. The genre's preference for them is also real. Both are in front of the reader.
For fifty-one years, Dr Diallo worked at this clinic. The work changed in many ways. The list of medicines available to her grew, as did the country's pharmaceutical infrastructure; the long-acting injectable contraceptives that became available in the mid-1980s shifted the texture of what was possible in a single consultation; vaccination programmes arrived, and her clinic was, in the late 1970s, one of the first in the region to offer the new childhood vaccination schedule. The roads to the surrounding villages were, in the 1990s, finally paved; the journey to Tola, which had taken her two and a half hours on foot in 1971, took thirty-five minutes by car in 2001. Some things did not change. The hardcover notebooks remained. The white coat, which she had been given as a graduation present by her uncle Boubacar — the second uncle, the one who said yes — was repaired three times by a tailor in the market and was still in use in 2018. She knew the name of every village health worker she had trained, and the names of their parents, and, in many cases, the names of their children. The article would like to note here, with some care, that giving the impression of a life of unbroken continuity is one of the things obituaries do, and that no life is, on close inspection, that continuous. There were difficult years; there were patients who died whom she did not, in retrospect, think she had served well; there were colleagues with whom she had professional disagreements that did not, in her own account, resolve cleanly. The family has not asked for these things to be excluded from the obituary. The article has, on inspection, mostly excluded them anyway, partly because the form prefers continuity, partly because writing about specific clinical disagreements would require more reporting than was available, partly because some of those colleagues are still living, and partly because the kind of obituary that includes such material has its own conventions and its own readership, and the obituary you are reading is not, on the whole, of that kind. The exclusion is worth registering. The continuity is not the whole truth.
From 1981 to 1990, she served as a senior adviser on child health to the Ministry of Health. She drove to the capital on Mondays and back to Mansa on Friday evenings, for nine years. The plan she helped to draft — a primary care framework that emphasised vaccination, clean water, maternal nutrition, antenatal monitoring, and the training of village health workers — became the basis of the national strategy until the early 2000s, and is widely thought, by those who study these things, to have saved a substantial number of children's lives. The framework was not hers alone. It was the result of collaboration with three named co-authors, two unnamed working groups, two consecutive ministers, and a regional health planning team that drew on technical assistance from international agencies whose role in shaping the framework's emphases was, in the historical record, both substantial and sometimes contested. To say that the framework was hers alone would be to misrepresent the work; she would have been the first to say so. To say that it was not hers in any meaningful sense would be to flatter a kind of self-effacement that, while real in her, had nothing to do with the underlying truth. The framework was the result of a particular collaboration, made possible by a particular government, in a particular decade, in which a particular woman from a small town with a particular history of clinical practice was at the centre of the drafting. The article would prefer to keep all four particulars in front of the reader at once.
She was, throughout her life, less interested in the formal recognition of her work than in the work itself. She received the national medal for service in 2009; she did not, by all accounts, attend the ceremony, sending her daughter Mariama in her place because the date conflicted with the antenatal clinic in Mansa. She was made an honorary fellow of the regional medical association in 2014; the certificate hung, framed, on the wall of the clinic, but in the room used for storing files, where most patients did not see it. She gave one extended interview to a documentary team, in 2018, on the condition that the team also spoke at length with three of the village health workers she had trained, and that the resulting film be shown first in Mansa and only then sent to film festivals. The film, on inspection, includes long sections in which Dr Diallo is silent and the health workers speak. There is a familiar professional pleasure in being the obituary writer who notices such gestures, frames them in the language of held complexity, and offers them to readers as evidence of a kind of attention the article is itself performing. The pleasure is real. So, I think, are the gestures. I am not certain that the second can be reliably distinguished from the first by any reader, including the writer. The film is, by any standard, a piece of generous self-presentation. The previous sentence is the kind of thing the obituary writer can say while still admiring her, and is the kind of thing the previous biographical paragraphs would not, on their own, have made room for.
Dozens of doctors in our country today were trained, in the final year of their medical education, at her clinic. Some of them lived in her house during their rural posting. They called her "Mama Awa", a name she neither encouraged nor discouraged. Dr Sory Camara, who is now in charge of the clinic together with her son Dr Ibrahim Bah, was one of those students. "She taught me how to listen to a patient," he said. "She would say: 'Sit down. Do not be in a hurry. The first thing the patient says is not always the most important thing. The first thing they say is the easiest thing. Wait for the second thing.' I have been a doctor for nineteen years. She was, on the central things, always right; on a small number of less central things, she was sometimes wrong. The capacity to be wrong about the small things while being right about the large was, I now think, a substantial part of what she had to teach." The remark is, on inspection, the most analytically generous thing said about her in this obituary, and it has been said by a younger man who has served in her clinic for more than nineteen years. I would prefer to leave it as the centre of the obituary, but I am aware that the form prefers a different kind of structural climax — usually a final image, a closing line, an evocative detail. The article will provide one of those in due course, partly because the form expects it, partly because to refuse it would itself be a recognisable move in the kind of long obituary I have come to write in this register, and the recursion has to stop somewhere. Some readers will find the self-awareness of the previous several paragraphs charming and others will find them the article's most calculated moves. Both readings are available. I am not going to choose between them, because choosing would itself be the next move in the same recognisable game.
Dr Diallo's husband, Mr Bah, died in 2018. She is survived by her four children, twelve grandchildren, and three great-grandchildren. The funeral will be held in Mansa on Friday morning. A memorial service for her colleagues and former students will be held at the regional medical association in the capital on the following Saturday. The clinic, which has been closed since Sunday, will reopen on Wednesday. Dr Ibrahim Bah and Dr Sory Camara will continue the work. The village health workers — eleven of whom are still in active service across the surrounding fourteen villages, and several more of whom have themselves taught the next generation — will continue theirs. The notebooks, which Dr Diallo's family has agreed to make available to medical historians from 2030 onwards, will continue to exist. The family has asked, in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme that has, in various forms, continued since the early 1980s, and that bears, in its current form, the name she gave it on its founding: Tanto, which in the local language means, approximately, 'go and look.'
I am ending the article here, on the name and its translation, partly because the closing image is what the form expects, partly because the name is genuinely good, partly because, after some hours of writing, ending elsewhere would feel like a refusal of a closing image that the obituary has earned, and partly because the writer is aware that ending on a meditation about the form would be the next move in the recursion, and the recursion has to stop somewhere. The life happened. The work continues. The notebooks will outlast the obituary. The form will outlast the writer. The recognisable shape into which her life has been folded will, in turn, be modified by the lives that come after hers and by the writers who attempt them. These are the relations. They are more interesting than any single conclusion the article could draw, and the article would prefer to end on them, with their costs and consolations, than on a conclusion it would have to discount as it offered. Tanto, the local language has it. Go and look. She did, for fifty-one years. The obituary has tried, for some hours, to do the same, and has the limits, and the small particular accomplishments, of any such trying.
Key Vocabulary
by indirection phrase
indirectly; not by direct statement but by suggestion or arrangement
"A small physical detail that does the work of summary by indirection."
moral parable noun phrase
a short story whose main work is to teach a moral lesson, often at the cost of nuance
"Convert a slow, structurally conditioned, often partial life into a sequence of moral parables."
curatorial space noun phrase
the space in a piece of writing devoted to a particular subject, especially when carefully arranged or shaped
"The figure of the supportive father has, in obituaries of distinguished women of this period, been given a particular kind of curatorial space."
structural climax noun phrase
the moment in a piece of writing where the form expects the highest emphasis or release of tension
"The form prefers a different kind of structural climax — usually a final image, a closing line, an evocative detail."
recursion noun
the situation in which an act of self-awareness becomes the next thing to be aware of, producing an infinite regress
"The recursion has to stop somewhere."
free indirect style noun phrase
(in narrative writing) a technique that lets the narration briefly take on the voice or perspective of an institution or character without quotation
"(The article uses this technique when writing in the voice of administrative documents or institutional positions.)"
to register (without using) verb
(in journalism) to acknowledge or note something seriously without exploiting it for narrative effect
"The article would prefer to register this rather than to claim it has cleanly avoided it."
consolidation (into a recognisable shape) noun
the process by which several similar treatments come to share a settled form
"The consolidation into a recognisable shape."
in lieu of phrase
instead of; in place of (used especially in formal notices, often around funerals)
"The family has asked, in lieu of flowers, that contributions be made to the village health worker training programme."
consolations noun (plural)
small comforts found in difficult situations; the goods that remain when more obvious goods are lost
"Their costs and consolations."
self-presentation noun
the way a person arranges how they appear to others, often blending honesty with calculation
"A piece of generous self-presentation."
cumulative work (of language) noun phrase
the slow effect produced by the repeated use of particular phrases over many texts and many years
"Each of which, accumulating across thousands of obituaries over decades, has done a particular kind of cumulative work."
the form (of the obituary) noun phrase
the recognised set of conventions — opening fact, family quotation, closing image — that shape what an obituary can do
"The form has done its work."
approximately adverb
roughly; close to but not exactly
"Tanto, which in the local language means, approximately, 'go and look.'"
Questions
Comprehension
  • What does the writer say is the cumulative effect of phrases like 'a trailblazer who never lost her humility' and 'her spirit will live on in the village she loved'?
    Answer
    The cumulative effect is a picture of distinguished women in twentieth-century medicine in which individual virtue and patient organising tend to produce, on a roughly human timescale, more or less complete and recognisable lives; in which the role of changing infrastructure and of changing financial and political pressure is somewhat secondary; and in which the more accurate and less flattering picture — that such lives were partial, contingent, expensive in particular ways, often dependent on temporary alignments of policy and institutional interest, and frequently in tension with the people who later wrote about them — is, on the whole, not visible.
  • What does the writer say is the 'particular trick' the obituary will perform throughout?
    Answer
    The trick is the implicit suggestion that, by analysing the form of the obituary, the article is somehow standing outside it. The article is not standing outside it. It is being written for the same newspaper that will run several other obituaries this week, in broadly the same register, by writers with broadly the same training. It is using, with adjustment, several of the same moves — the careful opening, the family quotation, the timely institution, the closing image. The principal difference is that the article is naming the moves as it makes them — a smaller difference than the article occasionally implies.
  • What does the writer say about the convention of the supportive father, and about the article's use of it?
    Answer
    The figure of the supportive father has, in obituaries of distinguished women of this period and region, been given a particular kind of curatorial space — admiring, slightly idealised, in some cases overdoing the moral credit. This article does not escape the convention. Mr Mamadou Diallo has been written well of here, partly because he was the kind of man the convention depicts and partly because the convention does the work. The convention tends to produce a particular shape of story in which a single father's persistence stands in for a wider network of women who also made the path possible.
  • What does the writer say about the notebooks, and about the genre's relationship with such artefacts?
    Answer
    The notebooks were the operating system of a small primary-care practice in a place where the formal infrastructure was thin. They were infrastructure that one woman had constructed because the surrounding infrastructure was not adequate. They are real. The genre's preference for foregrounding such artefacts — the kind of object obituaries of distinguished women of this generation have come to highlight — is also real. Both are in front of the reader.
  • What does the writer say about why difficult years and unresolved disagreements have mostly been excluded?
    Answer
    Partly because the form prefers continuity, partly because writing about specific clinical disagreements would require more reporting than was available, partly because some of those colleagues are still living, and partly because the kind of obituary that includes such material has its own conventions and its own readership, and this obituary is not, on the whole, of that kind. The exclusion is worth registering. The continuity is not the whole truth.
  • How does the article actually end, and what does the writer say about the ending?
    Answer
    The article ends on the name 'Tanto' and its translation 'go and look', partly because the closing image is what the form expects, partly because the name is genuinely good, partly because ending elsewhere would feel like a refusal of a closing image the obituary has earned, and partly because ending on a meditation about the form would be the next move in the recursion, and the recursion has to stop somewhere. The article ends on the relations between the morning's facts, with their costs and consolations, rather than on a single conclusion.
Vocabulary
  • What is the writer doing with 'consolidation into a recognisable shape' as a description of obituaries of distinguished women in the global south?
    Answer
    The phrase names a real but undertheorised process. Each individual obituary is responsive to the life it covers; cumulatively, however, obituaries of similar profiles have come to share a settled shape — supportive father, timely institution, lonely cohort, return to small place, decades of practice, modest response to recognition, closing physical detail. The phrase 'consolidation into a recognisable shape' allows the writer to name this without disparaging any individual obituary. It does precise structural work.
  • What is the rhetorical work of 'by indirection' in 'a small physical detail that does the work of summary by indirection'?
    Answer
    The phrase identifies a particular literary technique. The form's closing image — the chair, the white coat, the notebooks, the translated name — does not state what the life amounted to; it lets the detail carry the weight, by suggestion. By calling this 'work by indirection', the writer is naming the technique as a technique, not pretending it is innocent. The phrase allows the writer to acknowledge that the technique has been used while still using it.
  • What does the writer mean by 'cumulative work' in 'has done a particular kind of cumulative work'?
    Answer
    Cumulative work is the slow effect produced by the repeated use of particular phrases over many texts and many years. No single phrase does much. A phrase used ten thousand times across decades does a great deal — it shapes what readers expect, what writers reach for, what institutions assume. The phrase allows the writer to claim that obituary writing's stock vocabulary has political effects without singling out any individual writer for blame; the work is structural, accomplished by accumulation.
  • What does the writer mean by 'recursion' in 'the recursion has to stop somewhere'?
    Answer
    Recursion is the loop produced when the writer becomes aware of their own moves and then becomes aware of becoming aware of them. Each layer of self-awareness becomes the next thing to be self-aware about. The writer is naming the loop and choosing to stop it at a particular point — not because there is a natural stopping place but because going further would itself be the next move in the same recognisable game. The phrase is a small piece of writerly accountability.
  • What does the writer mean by 'consolations' in 'their costs and consolations'?
    Answer
    Consolations are the smaller goods that remain when the larger goods one was hoping for are not available — the work continued, the notebooks survive, the village health worker programme continues, the doctors she trained are now training others — even where complete recognition or biographical justice cannot be delivered by an obituary. The word allows the writer to give these goods their proper weight without pretending they replace the larger one. The closing 'their costs and consolations' is more precise than 'pros and cons' and acknowledges that what is being weighed includes real losses and real, smaller, gains.
Inference
  • Why does the writer admit that the article is 'using, with adjustment, several of the same moves' as the standard obituary?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the alternative — claiming the article occupies a position outside the form — would be a small dishonesty the article has consistently refused. The writer is inside the form, doing slightly different things with it, but not above it. By naming this, the writer earns a more credible kind of authority than the writer who poses outside. The naming costs the article some of its analytical glamour to make, and the cost is part of the honesty.
  • Why does the writer say that calling Dr Camara's remark 'the most analytically generous thing said about her in this obituary' has been said by 'a younger man who has served in her clinic for more than nineteen years'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the source of the remark matters. Dr Camara is not a relative; not a journalist; not a senior colleague awarding a tribute. He has spent nineteen years inside the practice she built. His remark is technical and qualified — she was right on the central things, sometimes wrong on small ones, and the proportion was the lesson. The article is saying that the most accurate account of her may not come from the closing image but from a paragraph in the middle, in which a colleague is allowed to be technical and unsentimental. The structural placement is itself part of the writer's claim.
  • Why does the writer say that ending on a meditation about the form 'would be the next move in the recursion'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the writer has already named several recognisable moves of long-form obituary writing in the present moment, including the move of refusing the standard closing image. To end on that refusal would be to make the article's own closing image its own self-awareness — which is itself a move that long-form newspaper obituaries have come to favour. The writer is acknowledging that the recursion of meta-commentary cannot be an exit from the form; it is, at best, a slightly different kind of position inside the form. Naming this is a precondition for honest closure.
  • Why does the writer choose 'Tanto' / 'go and look' as the closing detail despite admitting it is 'conveniently apt'?
    Suggested interpretation
    Because the name is real, the translation is accurate, and the detail is what the form expects. The writer admits the convenience to register that the writer is aware of the choice. Refusing the detail because it is convenient would be its own kind of mannerism. By using the detail and naming the convenience, the writer asks the reader to weigh both. The honesty does not undo the use; it complicates it. The closing is, in the end, what it is — a real translation of a real name, used as a closing image because closing images do this work in this form.
Discussion
  • The article claims that obituaries of distinguished women in the global south have, over the last twenty years, consolidated into a recognisable shape. If this is true, what does the consolidation cost individual lives, and what (if anything) should obituary writers now be doing differently?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. COSTS — the consolidation makes individual particularity less visible; lives that do not fit the shape are slightly distorted to fit it; readers are trained to expect a certain story. NOT MUCH COST — recognisable shapes do work; they help readers locate the life within a tradition; the shape is responsive to the lives. WHAT TO DO — pair such pieces with longer profiles, audio interviews, archival publications; let multiple registers coexist; resist treating the obituary as the canonical record. PROBABLY ALL OF THESE. A useful question.
  • The writer says the article has excluded difficult years and unresolved disagreements 'partly because the kind of obituary that includes such material has its own conventions and its own readership, and the obituary you are reading is not, on the whole, of that kind'. Is this an honest acknowledgement of genre limits, or an evasion of harder reporting?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. HONEST — different kinds of writing about lives serve different purposes; one obituary cannot do all of them; pretending it could would be the evasion. EVASIVE — the writer could have done more reporting; settling for naming the gap is convenient. PROBABLY THE ARTICLE'S CHOICE IS A REASONABLE ONE within its genre, given time and access constraints, while also being limited. A useful question about the practical economy of obituary writing.
  • The article distinguishes Dr Camara's 'analytically generous' remark from undivided praise, and suggests it is the closest the obituary comes to the truth. Is this the right standard for obituaries — accurate qualification rather than wholehearted praise — or does it underestimate what obituaries are for?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — accuracy honours the dead more than enthusiasm; flattening someone into praise misses who they were. UNDERESTIMATES — obituaries also serve mourning, and emotional simplicity is part of their work; analytical qualification can feel cold to the bereaved. PROBABLY BOTH KINDS NEEDED — the qualified version is more accurate; the simpler version is what families and communities often need; mature publications can do both. A useful question about the form's purposes.
  • What kinds of voices, perspectives, or experiences are missing from this obituary, and what might the absences tell us about the form?
    Discussion prompts
    PRESENT: family (brother, daughter, son), colleague (Camara), the writer's voice. ABSENT or UNDERREPRESENTED: patients themselves quoted directly; women who chose not to use her clinic; the two women from her medical school year who left medicine, beyond a published account directed to elsewhere; her husband Mr Bah's voice (he died in 2018); local critics or rivals; nurses and clinic staff; village health workers in their own voices; the eldest uncle who declined; the international agencies whose role is mentioned but not unpacked. The form gives voice to immediate family and to a senior colleague. A useful question.
  • What is the strongest critique of this obituary? Where might a serious, hostile reader say the writer's self-awareness becomes the article's primary form of self-presentation?
    Discussion prompts
    Possible critiques: that the meta-commentary is itself a literary performance that buys credit for noticing; that admitting to using the conventions is a form of plausible deniability that does not undo the conventions; that the closing refusal to choose between 'charming' and 'calculated' is the most calculated move; that the writer's voice has more space than would be standard, and does political work the article does not declare; that admitting to the convenient aptness of 'go and look' while still using it is the most refined form of the form's habits; that the article is, in the end, a sophisticated long-form piece that performs sympathy with the subject while doing its own kind of professional work in the same direction; that the central distinction between 'registering' and 'using' is a writerly self-flattery, since it gives the writer credit for caring about a boundary the writer is also crossing. A useful final question.
  • The article ends by holding open the question of whether its self-awareness is honest pluralism, evasion, or a recognisable signature move that has become its own kind of evasion. Is this the right way to end such an obituary?
    Discussion prompts
    Multiple positions. RIGHT — the writer cannot know how each reader will read the article; refusing to declare a single correct reading respects the reader's autonomy. WRONG — the writer should commit to a position rather than leaving the reader to assemble one; choosing not to choose is itself a position. RIGHT FOR THIS LIFE — Dr Diallo's own work made room for many positions to coexist; the obituary's openness is responsive to that. RECOGNISABLE — writers in this register have been ending pieces this way for some time; what was once principled is now a mark of the genre. PROBABLY ALL OF THESE. A genuinely difficult question.
Personal
  • Has anyone in your life or community been remembered in published or written form, and did the written version match the person you knew? What was missing, what was added, and what does the gap tell you about the form of writing about the dead?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My grandmother — the published version was kinder than the woman, but accurate'; 'A teacher — the obituary missed the strictness'; 'A neighbour — the written version made him sound more important than he was'; 'I have not yet had this experience'. Be warm. The question often produces real material about the gap between life and form.
  • Dr Camara says the capacity to be wrong about small things while being right about the large was 'a substantial part of what she had to teach'. Is there a person in your life who has shown you something similar — a way of holding the proportion between large and small? What did you learn?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'My grandmother — generous in matters that mattered, exacting about small habits'; 'A teacher who let small mistakes pass and was strict about ideas'; 'A friend who is wrong about small things but always right when it matters'; 'I am still working out the proportion in myself'. Be warm. The question is reflective.
  • Has reading this obituary changed, in any small way, what you will notice when you next read coverage of a distinguished life that has just ended? If yes, what?
    Teacher guidance
    Students' own answers. Common answers: 'Yes — I will notice the stock phrases'; 'Yes — I will notice whose voices are absent'; 'Yes — I will notice the closing detail and what it is doing'; 'Probably yes, but I will probably forget within a week, and reverting to old habits is itself worth noting'; 'Not really — I read these for what they tell me about the person'. Be warm.
Writing Task
Prompt
Write a long-form, self-aware obituary (700–900 words) for a fictional figure whose life would deserve serious treatment in a national newspaper. The obituary should both perform the conventions of the genre and interrogate them as it goes. Use periodic sentences. Hold at least one tension open without resolving it. Either refuse a closing image you have available, OR refuse to choose between two available readings of your own move at the end — whichever is harder for you. Disclose the conditions of production rather than letting them remain invisible. Risk a small specific claim about how the obituary form does a particular kind of work over time. The obituary's central commitment should be honesty about what the form can and cannot do, and about your own implication in the form, while still serving the dead.
Model Answer

Mr Imran Latif, who looked after the lock and the surrounding stretch of canal at Westwood for forty-six years and who was, by the time of his retirement in 2019, the longest-serving lock-keeper on the regional canal network, died at his home on Sunday morning. He was eighty-one. He had been ill for several months but had continued to walk the towpath, in a reduced way, until July of this year. The obituary that follows is, by the standards of the genre, long. It will spend a substantial portion of its length not on the chronology of his life but on the conditions under which lives such as his come to be written about, partly because those conditions are interesting in their own right and partly because the standard obituary of a long-serving public servant in a small place has been written, very competently, several thousand times in the last forty years, and one further such obituary would not, on the most charitable assessment, contribute much.

It is at this point in any obituary of this kind that the writer encounters a particular pressure that the reader may, with some justice, want named. The pressure is to use, without examining, a set of phrases — 'a quiet steward of our waterways', 'a man whose name was synonymous with the canal he tended', 'his dedication to a vanishing way of life'. Each of these phrases has, in the present moment, become part of how lives such as his are reported, and each has done a particular kind of cumulative work over decades. The work is to convert a slow, structurally conditioned, occasionally bureaucratic life of public service into a sequence of moral parables about lost crafts. I have written paragraphs containing such phrases. I am not going to use them in this obituary. I am also not going to take credit for their absence; it is the minimum a serious obituary of Mr Latif owes him.

Mr Latif was born in Westwood in 1944, in a small house owned by the canal company. His father had been a lock-keeper before him, on a different stretch of canal further south. His mother, who had been a textile worker before her marriage, had taught him to keep accounts. He left school at fifteen to work for the canal company, which was, in 1959, still the only employer of any size in the area. The combination of his father's apprenticeship and the company's training scheme — the latter discontinued in 1981, as part of the wider restructuring of the canal network that has since reduced full-time lock-keeping posts by approximately seventy per cent — was, in retrospect, the structural condition that made the rest possible. The figure of the timely apprenticeship has, in obituaries of long-serving canal workers of this generation, been given a particular curatorial space. This obituary does not, on close inspection, escape the convention.

Mrs Sara Davies, a former regional inspector, said: "He kept the lock running through three different ownership regimes, two automation projects that did not fully take, and one serious flood. He was, on the technical questions, almost always right, and, on a small number of less central matters, sometimes wrong. The capacity to be reliably right on the central things while open to being wrong on small ones is a substantial part of what makes a long-serving public servant useful. Imran had it."

The obituary would prefer to register that there were difficult years; there were arguments with the canal company that did not, in his own account, resolve cleanly; there were colleagues with whom he had professional disagreements that he carried without complaint but did not, on inspection, forget. The article has, on inspection, mostly excluded these. The exclusion is partly because the form prefers continuity, partly because the reporting was time-limited, and partly because the kind of obituary that includes such material has its own conventions and its own readership, and this obituary is not, on the whole, of that kind.

Mr Latif is survived by his wife, two children, and four grandchildren. The funeral will be held at Westwood village church on Friday morning. The lock, which has been operated by an automated system since 2019, was, on the morning of his death, opened manually for one hour by his son and his old apprentice, who walked the towpath in a slow loop and returned home without comment. I am ending the article here, on the manually opened lock, partly because the closing image is what the form expects, partly because the gesture is genuinely good, partly because, after some hours of writing, ending elsewhere would feel like a refusal of a closing image that the obituary has earned, and partly because the writer is aware that ending on a meditation about the form would be the next move in the recursion, and the recursion has to stop somewhere. The lock is now closed. It will be opened by the automated system at eight o'clock tomorrow morning, and at eight o'clock the morning after, for as long as the canal remains in use.

Activities
  • Form audit: in pairs, students take the second paragraph (where the writer lists the standard phrases of the obituary genre) and check, paragraph by paragraph, whether the article does or does not use each. Discuss the relationship between announcement and use.
  • The trick paragraph: in pairs, students take the paragraph in which the writer admits to the 'trick' of suggesting the article stands outside the form. Discuss whether the admission undoes the trick or merely converts it into a more sophisticated version.
  • Periodic sentences: students find three periodic sentences in the article and rewrite each as a series of short sentences. Read both versions aloud. Discuss what the periodic structure does that the short version cannot.
  • Free indirect style: in pairs, students locate moments in which the narrative voice briefly sounds like the voice of an institution or a convention without quotation. Discuss the effect.
  • The recursion question: in groups, students discuss the writer's claim that 'the recursion has to stop somewhere'. Apply the observation to other genres they read regularly — political commentary, criticism, memoir, biography.
  • The strongest critique: in pairs, students write a one-paragraph critique of the article in the voice of a serious, hostile reader. Then, in the voice of the writer, they respond to it. The exchange must be genuinely tested.
  • Genre comparison: in groups, students compare this article with a piece of standard obituary writing (any reputable national paper will do). They list five things the article can do that the standard version cannot, and three things the standard version can do that the article cannot.
  • The consolidation frame: in pairs, students discuss the writer's claim that obituaries of distinguished women in the global south have consolidated into a recognisable shape. Apply the frame to obituaries of other groups — long-serving public servants, distinguished men of one profession, neighbourhood figures.
  • Sentence frames: 'It is at this point in any obituary of this kind that the writer encounters a particular pressure that the reader may, with some justice, want named.' 'There is a particular trick the article has been performing throughout, which it would now be evasive not to name.' 'I am ending the article here, partly because ___, partly because ___, and partly because ___.' Each student writes a paragraph using one of these as a turning point.
  • Disclosing politics: students draft a single paragraph on a topic they care about, in which they state their position openly and then make a small careful argument for it. Share with a partner, who marks where the openness strengthens the writing and where it tips into self-presentation.
  • Final reading: each student selects what they think is the article's single most achieved sentence — the one that, on close inspection, does most work — and prepares to defend their choice. In a closing class discussion, students hear several candidates and discuss what 'most work' has come to mean across the readings.

⭐ Ratings & Comments

How useful did you find this text? Leave a rating and a comment to help other teachers.

Your rating:
No rating