Dante Alighieri (1265-1321) was an Italian poet, writer, and political thinker. He was born in Florence, one of the most important cities in medieval Italy, into a family of modest nobility. He fell deeply in love as a young man with a woman named Beatrice, who died young and became the central figure of his poetic imagination. He was active in Florentine politics and held several public offices. In 1301, when a rival political faction took power in Florence, Dante was accused of political offences, sentenced to death if he returned, and exiled from his city forever. He never went back. He spent the rest of his life wandering from city to city in northern Italy, writing, and composing the work for which he is remembered above all others: the Commedia, known in English as the Divine Comedy. This long narrative poem, written in Italian rather than the Latin used by educated writers of the time, describes a journey through Hell, Purgatory, and Heaven. It was immediately recognised as a masterpiece and has remained one of the most admired works in world literature for seven hundred years.
Dante matters for several connected reasons. The Divine Comedy is one of the deepest explorations of the human condition ever written, using the framework of a journey through the afterlife to examine what it means to live well or badly, to be responsible for your choices, to understand justice and mercy, and to seek genuine knowledge and love. He also matters historically: by choosing to write in Italian rather than Latin, he made a decisive statement that the vernacular language of ordinary people was capable of the highest literary achievement. He helped create literary Italian and demonstrated that poetry in living languages could reach the depths that classical Latin and Greek had reached. His poem contains a vast range of knowledge: theology, philosophy, astronomy, politics, and personal history are all woven together. It is also, at its core, a poem about one person's intellectual and spiritual journey from confusion and error towards understanding: a journey that every reader is invited to take alongside him.
Robin Kirkpatrick's translation of the Divine Comedy (Penguin Classics, three volumes) is the most accessible scholarly translation and includes helpful introductions and notes. Clive James's one-volume verse translation (Picador, 2013) is more freely translated but captures the poem's energy. For a short introduction: A. N. Wilson's Dante in Love (2011, Atlantic Books) is an accessible account of Dante's life and the poem's background. The Dante Society of America maintains freely accessible resources at dante.dartmouth.edu.
Etienne Gilson's Dante and Philosophy (1949, Harper) is the classic account of Dante's intellectual sources.
Joan Ferrante's The Political Vision of the Divine Comedy (1984, Princeton) examines Dante's engagement with the politics of his time.
Matthew Pearl's The Dante Club (2003, Random House) is a historical novel that gives a vivid sense of Dante's reception in nineteenth-century America.
The Divine Comedy is primarily about the afterlife and is therefore only relevant to religious people.
While the Divine Comedy uses the framework of Christian theology, its concerns are universal. Hell, Purgatory, and Heaven are Dante's way of exploring what different ways of living lead to: what kind of person you become through your choices. The poem is a profound exploration of justice, love, freedom, responsibility, knowledge, and the human condition that has been found meaningful by readers across many centuries and many different cultural and religious backgrounds. Many of the poem's most insightful readers, including T.S. Eliot, Jorge Luis Borges, and Umberto Eco, read it primarily as a literary and philosophical rather than a theological work.
Dante was endorsing cruelty and revenge by placing his enemies in Hell.
Dante's placement of real historical figures in Hell was a political and moral statement, not a personal revenge fantasy, though personal feeling is certainly present. His judgments were based on a coherent moral and theological framework, and he placed figures he admired and even loved in Hell when his framework required it. He places his own teacher Brunetto Latini in Hell with evident grief. He is also capable of great sympathy for those he condemns: the episode of Paolo and Francesca in the Inferno is one of the most compassionate passages in the poem, even as it describes their damnation.
The Divine Comedy is too difficult and obscure to be read by non-specialists.
The Divine Comedy can certainly be read with extensive scholarly annotation, but it can also be read as a narrative poem of great emotional power and imaginative vividness without specialist knowledge. The opening image, the dark wood and the lost way, the encounters with famous historical figures, the extraordinary descriptions of Hell, Purgatory, and Heaven, and the final vision of love as the force that moves the universe are accessible to any careful reader. Good translations, such as those by Robert Hollander, Robin Kirkpatrick, and Clive James, make the poem available in English with enough annotation to be rewarding without being overwhelming.
Dante was simply a medieval Christian writer whose worldview is no longer relevant.
Dante's worldview was specifically medieval and Catholic, but the questions he explores are perennial: what does it mean to live well? what are the consequences of the choices we make? what is the relationship between reason and other ways of knowing? what is justice? what is love at its highest? These questions are not made obsolete by changes in religious or cultural context. Seven centuries of readers across very different cultures and belief systems have found the poem profoundly relevant to their own lives precisely because it engages with questions that do not go away.
Charles Singleton's six-volume commentary on the Divine Comedy (Princeton University Press) is the most thorough scholarly treatment in English.
Umberto Eco's The Aesthetics of Thomas Aquinas (1956, Harvard University Press) examines the medieval aesthetic tradition that shaped Dante.
T.S. Eliot's essay Dante (1929) is one of the most penetrating accounts of what makes the poem so powerful. Jorge Luis Borges's essays on Dante, collected in Seven Nights (1984, New Directions), offer a distinctive and illuminating perspective from a major twentieth-century writer.
Your feedback helps other teachers and helps us improve TeachAnyClass.