Grammar for Teachers
Grammar for Teachers
🟡 Intermediate

Sentence Structure: Noun Clauses — That, What, Whether, and Wh- Words

What this session covers

A noun clause is a subordinate clause that functions as a noun — it can be the subject or the object of a sentence. Noun clauses appear constantly in academic and formal writing, in reported speech, and in sophisticated everyday conversation. They are formed using that, what, whether, and wh- words (who, where, when, why, how). Understanding how they work is one of the most important steps towards producing complex, well-structured writing.

Personal Reflection

Before you start — think honestly about your own teaching and experience.

Q1
How confident do you feel producing and teaching noun clauses — and explaining why 'I know where she is' uses statement word order?
Q2
Which of these have you experienced? (Select all that apply)

Discover the Pattern

Look at the examples. Answer each question before reading the explanation — this is how your students will learn too.

1

Read these sentences. In each one, part of the sentence is acting like a noun — it is the subject or the object of the main verb. Can you identify which part acts as a noun?

She knows that the results will be announced tomorrow. (object of 'knows')
What she said in the meeting was very important. (subject of 'was')
I wonder whether they have received our letter. (object of 'wonder')
Nobody knows where the missing textbooks are. (object of 'knows')
The fact that she passed was a great surprise to everyone. (the 'that' clause is an appositive — it explains 'the fact')
In each sentence, could you replace the noun clause with a simple noun? What would you lose?

Noun clauses function exactly like nouns — they can be replaced by a pronoun or noun: 'She knows IT', 'THIS was very important', 'I wonder ABOUT IT', 'Nobody knows IT'. The noun clause gives much richer, more specific information than a simple noun. 'She knows the result' vs. 'She knows that the results will be announced tomorrow' — the noun clause contains a complete idea. This is why noun clauses are so important in academic and formal writing — they allow writers to embed complex ideas as subjects or objects of sentences. There are three main types: that-clauses (she said that...), wh-clauses (I know where..., I know who...), and whether/if-clauses (I wonder whether...).'

2

Now look at the word order inside noun clauses. Compare these sentences:

A. Where is she going? (question — inverted word order)
B. I know where she is going. (noun clause — statement word order)
A. Who did she talk to? (question — inverted)
B. I wonder who she talked to. (noun clause — statement word order)
A. What time does the meeting start? (question — inverted)
B. Can you tell me what time the meeting starts? (noun clause — statement word order)
What happens to the word order when a question becomes a noun clause?

When a wh- question becomes a noun clause, the inverted word order (auxiliary before subject) changes back to statement word order. 'Where IS she going?' (question inversion) → 'I know where she IS going' (statement order — no inversion). 'What time DOES the meeting start?' → 'what time the meeting STARTS' (statement order). This is exactly the same rule as for indirect questions (covered in the questions series) — and the same reason applies: the question marker is carried by the main verb ('I know', 'I wonder', 'tell me'), not by the embedded clause. Inside a noun clause, statement word order always applies. This is one of the most frequent and persistent errors in student writing.'

3

Now look at that-clauses. When can 'that' be omitted? When must it be kept?

She said (that) she would come. (that can be omitted — informal)
I think (that) the results are good. (that can be omitted — informal)
The fact that she passed surprised everyone. (that MUST be kept — cannot be omitted)
It is important that all teachers attend. (that usually kept — formal)
She is aware that the deadline has passed. (that usually kept after adjective + of)
When should 'that' be omitted and when should it be kept?

After common verbs of saying and thinking (say, think, believe, know, hope, feel), 'that' is often omitted in informal speech and writing. 'She said she would come.' 'I think it's good.' In formal and academic writing, keeping 'that' is generally preferred — it makes the sentence clearer and more careful. 'That' must be kept when the noun clause is the subject: 'That she passed was unexpected.' (or rephrase with 'it': 'It was unexpected that she passed.') 'That' should be kept after certain nouns (the fact that, the idea that, the possibility that, the claim that) and after some adjectives (aware that, certain that, confident that). In formal academic writing, the safest rule is: keep 'that'. It is never wrong to include it.'

The Pattern — What You Just Discovered

A noun clause is a subordinate clause that functions as a noun — as the subject or object of a sentence. There are three types: that-clauses, wh-clauses, and whether/if-clauses. Inside a noun clause, statement word order (not question word order) is always used. 'That' can often be omitted in informal contexts after verbs of saying and thinking, but is generally kept in formal writing.
Special Rule / Notes

NOUN CLAUSES IN ACADEMIC AND FORMAL WRITING:

Noun clauses are the architecture of academic and formal writing. They appear in:

REPORTED SPEECH AND THOUGHT:

The report suggests that funding has decreased significantly.
The research shows that early intervention is more effective.
Teachers report that class sizes are increasing.

FORMAL ARGUMENT:

It is clear that more resources are needed.
It remains unclear whether the policy will be implemented.
The evidence indicates that students learn best in smaller groups.

AFTER CERTAIN ADJECTIVES + THAT:
Sure that, confident that, aware that, certain that, surprised that, pleased that, concerned that:

She was confident that the students would succeed.
We are concerned that the deadline may not be met.

AFTER CERTAIN NOUNS + THAT:
The fact that, the idea that, the claim that, the possibility that, the suggestion that, the belief that:

The fact that the school had no library was a serious problem.
The suggestion that class sizes should increase was unpopular.

IN ALL THESE CONTEXTS: keep 'that' — do not omit it in formal writing.

🎥

Can you replace the clause with a pronoun (it, this, something)? → it is a noun clause. Is the word order inside the clause inverted (auxiliary before subject)? → wrong — change to statement order. Is the clause a subject? → consider using 'it' as a dummy subject. Is the context formal or academic? → keep 'that', don't omit it. Is the embedded question yes/no (no wh- word)? → use whether (formal) or if (informal).

Common Student Errors

I know where is she going.
I know where she is going.
WhyInside a noun clause, use statement word order — not question word order. 'Where she is going' (subject + auxiliary + verb) — not 'where is she' (question inversion).
She asked me what does the teacher want.
She asked me what the teacher wants.
WhyStatement word order inside the noun clause. 'What the teacher wants' — not 'what does the teacher want'. Remove 'does' and return to standard statement order.
Nobody knows why the results were not announced. This sentence is actually CORRECT. | NOTE: 'Why the results were not announced' uses statement word order correctly — 'the results' is the subject, 'were not announced' is the passive verb. Students sometimes doubt this because they confuse it with question word order.
If she will accept the position is still unknown.
Whether she will accept the position is still unknown.
WhyAt the start of a sentence as the subject, 'whether' is strongly preferred over 'if'. 'If' at the start of a sentence sounds like a conditional clause, not a noun clause subject. Use 'whether' when the noun clause is the subject.
The fact she arrived early surprised everyone.
The fact that she arrived early surprised everyone.
WhyAfter the noun 'fact', 'that' cannot be omitted. The same applies to: the idea that, the possibility that, the claim that, the suggestion that. 'That' must be kept in these appositive noun clause patterns.

Check Your Understanding — Part 1

Choose the correct word or form to complete each noun clause. Think about what type of noun clause is needed and whether the word order is correct.

Nobody seems to know ___________ the examination results will be announced.
It is still uncertain ___________ the new policy will improve outcomes.
___________ she achieved in her first year of teaching is remarkable.
The research indicates ___________ smaller class sizes lead to better learning outcomes.
She was surprised ___________ so many parents attended the school event.
0 / 5 answered

Check Your Understanding — Part 2: Why Is It Wrong?

Each sentence contains an error. Write the correct version and explain why — then reveal the answer.

Can you explain why did the results improve so significantly?
Write the correct sentence:
Explain why it is wrong:
Can you explain why the results improved so significantly?
Inside a noun clause, use statement word order. 'Why the results improved' — not 'why did the results improve'. Remove 'did' and return the verb to past simple 'improved'. The wh- word goes first, then subject, then verb — no inversion.
If she will be appointed as director is still being discussed.
Write the correct sentence:
Explain why it is wrong:
Whether she will be appointed as director is still being discussed.
At the start of a sentence as the subject noun clause, use 'whether' — not 'if'. 'If' at the start of a sentence reads as a conditional clause. 'Whether she will be appointed' is the noun clause subject. 'Whether' clearly signals this is an embedded yes/no question acting as a noun.
The possibility the school might close was very worrying for parents.
Write the correct sentence:
Explain why it is wrong:
The possibility that the school might close was very worrying for parents.
After 'the possibility' (and other similar nouns: the fact, the idea, the claim, the suggestion), 'that' must be kept and cannot be omitted. 'The possibility that the school might close' — the 'that' links the noun to its explanatory clause.
I don't understand what does she want from this meeting.
Write the correct sentence:
Explain why it is wrong:
I don't understand what she wants from this meeting.
Statement word order inside the noun clause. 'What she wants' — not 'what does she want'. Remove 'does' and use the standard present simple 'wants' (agreeing with 'she'). Question inversion (does she want) is not used inside noun clauses.

Classroom Teaching Sequence

Use this sequence directly in class — guided discovery, no textbook needed. Tap each step to mark it done.

0 / 5 done
1

STEP 1 — THE NOUN CLAUSE AS REPLACEMENT (5 minutes): Write these sentences with a simple noun as object:

'She knows the answer.'
'I wonder about the decision.'
'Nobody understands the reason.'
Now expand each to use a noun clause:
'She knows that the results will be announced tomorrow.'
'I wonder whether they will accept the proposal.'
'Nobody understands why they made that decision.'
Establish: the noun clause does the same job as a noun, but contains a complete idea.
2

STEP 2 — WORD ORDER INSIDE NOUN CLAUSES (8 minutes): This is the most important step. Write two columns:
Question (inverted): 'Where IS she going?' / 'What DOES the report say?'
Noun clause (statement): 'I know where she IS going.' / 'She explained what the report SAYS.'
Drill: students hear a question, then embed it in 'I know that... / Nobody knows... / She explained...' They must change the word order. Do five examples together, then five in pairs.

3

STEP 3 — THAT, WHETHER, OR WH-? (5 minutes): Teach the three types through meaning:
'That' → introduces a statement: 'She knows THAT she passed.'
'Whether/if' → introduces a yes/no question: 'I wonder WHETHER she passed.'
'Wh- word' → introduces a specific question: 'I know WHEN she passed.'
Give students five sentences — they decide which type of noun clause opener is needed.

4

STEP 4 — FORMAL WRITING PATTERNS (8 minutes): Teach the most important formal patterns with noun clauses:
'The research shows that...'
'It is clear that...'
'The fact that... is...'
'It remains uncertain whether...'
'What is needed is...'
Students produce one sentence with each pattern about their school or community. Share and compare. This immediately builds academic and formal writing skill.

5

STEP 5 — SUBJECT CLAUSE PRACTICE (5 minutes): Teach the 'it' dummy subject pattern.

'That she passed was wonderful.' → 'It was wonderful that she passed.'
'Whether they will come is uncertain.' → 'It is uncertain whether they will come.'
Students convert five heavy subject clauses to the lighter 'it' version. This teaches a very common formal writing pattern.

Ready-to-Use Classroom Materials

Use directly in class — copy, adapt, or read aloud. No printing needed.

1 Question to Noun Clause — Conversion Drill (No materials)
Read each question aloud. Students embed it in the given frame as a noun clause — changing the word order from question order to statement order. Do the first one together. Listen carefully for any question inversion inside the noun clause and correct immediately.
Example sentences
'Where is the director's office?' → Nobody told me where the director's office is.
'What time does the meeting start?' → Can you tell me what time the meeting starts?
'Why were the results delayed?' → I don't understand why the results were delayed.
'Who made this decision?' → It is unclear who made this decision.
'How many students will be affected?' → The report explains how many students will be affected.
'Whether she accepted the offer' → It is not yet known whether she accepted the offer.
2 Formal Writing with Noun Clauses — Sentence Building (No materials)
Read each frame. Students complete it with a noun clause appropriate to their school or teaching context. They should aim to produce sentences that could appear in a formal report, letter, or academic document. Share and compare — discuss whether the word order inside the noun clause is correct.
Example sentences
The research suggests that ______.
It is important that all teachers ______.
The fact that ______ is a serious concern.
Nobody knows why ______.
It remains unclear whether ______.
What students need most is ______.
The evidence indicates that ______.
3 Error Hunt — Dictation (No materials)
Dictate these sentences. Students find and correct errors. Some sentences are correct — including one that looks wrong but is right. Discuss the rule behind each answer.
Example sentences
Nobody knows where is the headteacher. ✗ → where the headteacher is
She explained what the new policy means. ✓
If she will accept is still uncertain. ✗ → Whether she will accept
The fact that the school lacks resources is well known. ✓
I wonder whether they have received our application. ✓
She asked me what time does the meeting start. ✗ → what time the meeting starts
What she said at the meeting surprised everyone. ✓

Plan Your Next Steps

For each strategy, choose the option that best describes where you are now.

Teach the word order rule (statement order inside noun clauses) as a firm habit — it is the most frequent error and affects both written and spoken English
The 'it is... that/whether' pattern is extremely useful in formal writing — build it into every formal writing activity
Return to noun clauses in every reading text — they are very common and students who can recognise them understand texts much better
Connect to reported speech — reported speech is almost entirely built from noun clauses (she said that..., she asked whether..., she explained how...)
The next lesson covers sentence variety — how to write with variety and effect using different sentence types and structures
What is the one change you will make next time you teach this grammar point?

Key Takeaways

1 A noun clause functions as a noun — it can be the subject or object of a sentence. The three types: that-clauses, wh-clauses, and whether/if-clauses
2 Inside a noun clause, always use statement word order — never question inversion. 'I know where she is' (not 'where is she')
3 'That' can be omitted in informal contexts after verbs of saying/thinking, but should be kept in formal and academic writing
4 After the nouns fact, idea, possibility, suggestion, and claim, 'that' must always be kept: 'the fact that she came'
5 'Whether' is preferred over 'if' in formal contexts and whenever the clause is the subject of a sentence